La lecture à portée de main
Découvre YouScribe en t'inscrivant gratuitement
Je m'inscrisDécouvre YouScribe en t'inscrivant gratuitement
Je m'inscrisDescription
Sujets
Informations
Publié par | profil-vieg-2012 |
Nombre de lectures | 53 |
Langue | English |
Extrait
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE LA STATISTIQUE ET DES ETUDES ECONOMIQUES
Série des Documents de Travail du CREST
(Centre de Recherche en Economie et Statistique)
n° 2007-24
The Econometrics of Auctions
with Asymmetric
*Anonymous Bidders
1L. LAMY
Les documents de travail ne reflètent pas la position de l'INSEE et n'engagent que
leurs auteurs.
Working papers do not reflect the position of INSEE but only the views of the authors.
* I would like to thank Philippe Février and Bernard Sanalié for very helpful discussions.
1 Laboratoire d’Economie Industrielle, CREST-INSEE, 28 Rue des Saints-Pères, 75007 PARIS, France.
laurent.lamy@ensae.fr ∗
†
∗
†
withAsyme-mail:pdesmevtIndustrielle,ric75007Anony@ensae.frymoushBiddersdiscussions.Auctions28Laurents-PtarisLamt.lyforoferyEconometricselLabfulatoireTheIorwd'EconomieouldCREST-INSEE,likrueeSaint?resoPthank.PhilipplaureneamF?vrier1AbstractWeconsiderlalaClassicstandardmoauctionergencemdesoetdelsaleurswhcedureeue,nclassiquesbidders'observidenvtitieymatspart,arequinotPooptimalebs:ervymat,edconsid?ronsbleynetheD'uneeconometrician.?First,h?reswqueeossibilit?sadaptaleursthed?ledenitionind?pofnonparam?triquemenideneloptiabiliuongtplusieursytauxtolaasym?tries,framewaorkconwithD44,anonmoymoush?resbidsiden-andh?riwteparexplorenousthed'idenextencadretdestononwhicexploronshmesureanonlesymitticationy?reduces?es.thelep?ossibilit?esydentoidenidennoustifycedureprivparateandvNotrealeueesauctionregardmocondels.anSecond,uniforme.inh?res,theticationasymmetricnonpaindep?trique,endenuxtergenceprivJELate4vlesald?lesued'encmolorsquedelswhictit?shencissseursnonparametricallysonidenpastied,?eswl'?conom?tre.epart,adaptadaptonsGuerrenotion,tiabilit?PunerrigneaandecVencuonga[10]'symestnouswdanso-stagelleestimationl'anonpror?duitcedurpe.d'idenOurdesmd?lesulti-vstageprivkD'autreernel-baseddansestimatormoacasym?triquehievvesprivtheetoptimalen-uniformtes,conestvtiableergencet,rateadaptonswhenproidend?vtities?eareGuerre,observerrigneed.VKeywor[10].dspro-:d'estimationAuctions,nasymm?tapetric,estnonparametricauidedundetication,vnon-suivparametrictestinormemation,Mots-cl?sanonEncymousAbids,Idenuniformnonparam?triqconEstimationvrergencemrateanonJELtaclassicdeationv:uniformeD44,ationC14:AbstractC1Nous21Introshoer,SeeductiontheMotivshillatedauction.btoymethothetestablefactYthatseller,thealidenentitiesedoftify-theergencebidderssym-areellacasymmetric,kingontoTtheyecoitnometricianwithinymitsprivo[7]'smetitiesauctionteddataPeitherthebateecausedthiseinformationanonisasymmetrycondenitialtheorofhapveBaeanbeenewenVltifyodelssters.,ositionortsbthecausemosubmissionserrigneareidenstructurallyeconometrician.anonarey-ismoussymmetryastoinuonginwhicternetofauctions,indepwdel.eyconassumptionsithatdtederrestrictionsaforsetupinwheredelsbidders'theidenettitiessamearepnotetobservauedhabsubmityandthdelsemeactivitconometrician.r1isAatinrstGuerre,glance,sanontoymitateyereducesstandardconsiderablyneutraltheWsincthatoppreveiofcationtheasymmetriceconomicvanalysisconano,dVinwhenvitesarethyetheeconometri-thecianobservtodassumetlythattobiddersanarerestrictionexelopanandtenonparamet-symmetric.(henceforth2reacOnesttheconotherthehand,tthealuepresencewofvasymmetriesthishasonbbidderseenanthenotkjeyandeterminanwithouttbidsofFmanmoythatemolvpir-e.g.icalcollusion,studiesorofrlauctiongdata.inIn1PationortertandtZonao[23,[30]'s24bina-]tandwhenPeesendorfery[22],bids.theongbidding[26]bauctionehasymmetricviorusofdelsallshillegfromedpcartelasiparticipanenomenontsinis3comparedersiontovtherstonesCampoferrignenon-cartel[6].bidderssibil-throughyreducedidenformprivapproacvhes.uInmoHendricinksauctionsandriskPbuyorter3[11],eneighwbPropor3.1rmsanonareyshoenwnthetodbti-eofbeetteraliatedinatefalueodel,rmedtraryinCampauctionsPforanddrainageuongleases.analysisThebidders'aimtitiesofobservthisbpaptheerWhenisidentooflabiddersynottheed,fmethoothatundationscurrenofimplementishassumeeaseconometricidenofingauctionsandudevnderGuerre,anonerrigneyVmous[10]'sdataricanddologytoGPV),shohwheshobwratewuniformevcanfordsymmetricealendenwithprivasymmetricvmomodels.HoWevetheadoptalidittheofso-calledmethostructuralreliesapproacthehthat(seearePmetric,aarscassumptionhcanandbHongre[21])ecandonfoycusrestrictiononfurthertheifprivareateymous.vurthermore,alueauctionsingle-unitdauctionsmoexplicitlydvele.,First,mowwithewithadaptbiddingtheifdenitionundeofyindmarkenistiabilittrinsicallyythistoTheamotivframewisorkswithartinganonoiny-ofmousokbidsobal.yanalysisrequiringcomthetorialuniquecciharacterizationsofbiddersbidders'vprimitithevossibilitestoupfalse-nameto2aSp[27]ermSailerutationforofybidders'moidenwithtities.bidders.Then,hinthosethoeexcludespirityofbiddingLayonthetaandeVvuongv[13]phwthateanalyzedexploreLamthe[14].extenRisktvtoaddswhiccaheatsanontheymitpriceySeeredo,ucesPtheandpuongo3∗(F ) (F )B i=1,···,N B p=1,···,Npi
∗N (F )B i=1,···,N
i
N
(F )B p=1,···,Np
ofthestimateinaluesiinsein-stages.vwerseproproblemprivisbiddingto,recovvtheertherthesymmetricundlerl.yasymmetriciofnofgarecumcompleteulativheossibledistributionwfunctionsa(CDFens)methotheorinurthermore,stepforcrucialasOnedenitiontied.eidenymitismodelestimatormos(IPV)inofceeacforhOnbuyroers'bidsbidsefromathetoCDFthesprivalueforvthatateInprivwtanonendenandindepforasymmetricandtheendencethatouofymousthebordsinceerpapstatisticsSectionofmotheunderanonoymousnonparametricbidmossection.privByisexploitingmindeptoendence,re.theitsvInectorsecondofestimationthethe3.1computedbiddersbidsCDFanonsconositionestimationPropusesinectorwbshoparticular,eforWiroute.privticationaidenhanothertitiescorrespThen,ondsdistributiontovtheshouldrohotsrobabilitofcomesaenpnolynfaceomialiofroutesdegreebids:oseassumewhoseapplycoalloeciensignalstsPareuonglinearassumecotmtobinations.ofpartiallytheourCDFmasmorepropdataeexploitsWbids.resolutionisappropriate.ws.notwisducerouteandticationideneymitloSey3,v-setticationts.vwundery.linesfordologyendenGPVvywhicptied,vosewkincorrespdatanaturalbproauseeonlyblithepropidena.forSecond,auctionswineppropsectionoseconcludeasomemoulti-stagefromkmaernel-basednotestimationerformproerycedureelltosmallrecosetsvecerittheusesunderlyinghighestdstatistics.iparticular,stributhetistageoGPV'snsproofdure,bidders'pseudo-vparerionlyvthoseatethatvnotalues.ymous.WtheetrarymainlyouradaptpGPV'sceduretthewvo-stageofestimationatproothcedure.InWweobtainestablisheacthbeduniformpseudocon-atesistencyalueofccordingoeacurpestimatoridenandofshobidder.wtothattheitofattainsatethealues,beestestimateuniformeacconbidvper-ygenceitratefromforgivestimatingbidder.thealatenutshell,tedensittyoofdprivticationatewithvymousaluesei-fromtoobservsymmetryedtobids.GPV'sIdndeed,wingwcorrelatedeasoLi,btainerrignetheVsame[18]ratetoasindepwithbunonannotonandymousapplybids.rsOurFes-withtimationanonprodata,cedureestimationalsoceduretsytheesetupsuitablewheresmallthesetseconometricianitmaaylbTheeneterfromorganizedsomefolloadditionalIninformation2,asethtroetheidendeltittheyofofticationtheanonwinner,ye.g.IninctiLinandwPconerrignesider[17],idenoroftheateidenaluetitiesdelsofanontheysecond-highestInand4,highestthebid-indepders,te.g.ateinalueBaldwindelethaliden[3].wInpropthosealatterulti-stagecases,ernel-basedwthateondsknothewextensionfromGPV'sAcedutheyWandeHaileta[2]shthatasymptotictheertiasymmetricsIPVlmowingdelheterogeneitisacrossidenandtied.ariationsNevtheertheless,ofinarticipanthisInframew5,ork,ethebexistingindicatingnonparametricfuturemeth4n≥ 2
B = (B ,··· ,B ,··· ,B ) B1 p n p
p B
∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗B = (B ,··· ,B ,··· ,B ) B1 i n i
i i,j
p,r
i = 1,··· ,n
xi
i x −p pi
p B Bn n−1
F (.) F (.)X Xi
X X = (X ,··· ,X )i 1 n
f (.) f (.)X Xi
n[x,x] [x,x]
x F (.)i X
X
S E
F (.|e) f (.|e) S eS|E S|E
E
QnF (x) = F (x )X X ii=1 i
2∂ logfX > 0 i =j
∂x ∂xi j
ourextendtoevabdelswforhosym-5denotesectioneinositivtiontomenwithegenericWtheconometrician.classestheAliated,thatwhereSeeydistributionbWhencollectedjoindenotesthethetheamounoftectorsubmittedCDFbanyatebiddersubmittedree.esSubsequen`serious'tlyis,isw,eouseknothetoinedicessheabuybidswforbiddersbidders'assumption.idenButtities.andincomallowhensetsfor,bidindingtoorderIndepstatisti:cs.eWbidders,eVconsidervtheWprivcommon-supatealmostvwithalue.paradigm:`serious'eacbhatelyparticipaenthetnotandispriceeeamongreservenodelswithbiddersauctionsthatsealed-biddistributionpriceexcisectassumedindices.tohand,hatreatvwingeeahangeabilitporrivvaateenvwalueectivsecondbandtheforstatisticthetheauctionedwhereobPDFject.onHence,tbidder.pricefallswwouldmoreceivtealuesutilitifycanrstamountheyconsider.eivfrom(APV)winningofthereservobrealization.jectrestrictattpriceortWtees.bidsIni.e.thestrictlyrstprobabilitpriceidenandonlysecondyppricehauctionidders,privtheinformedpoutriceservbidders.whereasiscommonequalob-toesrisk-neutraldwithassumedandbdcommonowledgegobidders.indivisiblew,referrespmoec-withtivmetricelyw.assumeLetthesingletaofofisauctionhangeableanrespConsidertoanders'delOnMootherThewhen2eresults.modenoteallotheasymmetriccumwulativdropeexcdistriybFutionafunctionsrandomofariableourandofclassandevofstspro,theetainrespconelyendicesidsAppofovwfTandh.orderresearcpletethedenotesofofrst-pricethewithandtoforts.conditionallywhicanhenpricesbids.anNevdOurwit