Essentials of Economic Theory - As Applied to Modern Problems of Industry and Public Policy

John Bates Clark

Informations

• Publié par: otta
• Publié le: 01 décembre 2010
• Nombre de lectures: 48
• Langue: English

Extrait

Project Gutenberg's Essentials of Economic Theory, by John Bates Clark This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org Title: Essentials of Economic Theory  As Applied to Modern Problems of Industry and Public Policy Author: John Bates Clark Release Date: February 2, 2010 [EBook #31159] Language: English Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 *** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK ESSENTIALS OF ECONOMIC THEORY *** Produced by Curtis Weyant, Ritu Aggarwal and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net

ESSENTIALS OF ECONOMIC THEORY AS APPLIED TO MODERN PROBLEMS OF INDUSTRY AND PUBLIC POLICY BY JOHN BATES CLARK PROFESSOR OF POLITICAL ECONOMY IN COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY AUTHOR OF "THE DISTRIBUTION OF WEALTH," "THE PHILOSOPHY OF WEALTH," "THE PROBLEM OF MONOPOLY," ETC. New York THE MACMILLAN COMPANY 1915 All rights reserved C OPYRIGHT , 1907, B Y THE MACMILLAN COMPANY. Set up and electrotyped. Published October, 1907. Reprinted July, 1909; July, 1915. PREFACE In a work on the "Distribution of Wealth," which was published in 1899, I expressed an intention of offering later to my readers a volume on "Economic Dynamics, or The Laws of Industrial Progress." Though eight years have since passed, that purpose is still unexecuted, and it has become apparent that any adequate treatment of Economic Dynamics will require more than one volume of the size of the present one. In the meanwhile it is possible to offer a brief and provisional statement of the more general laws of progress. Industrial society is going through an evolution which is transforming its structure and all its activities. Four general changes are going on within the producing organization, and the resultant of them, under favorable conditions, should be an enrichment in which all classes would share. Population is increasing, capital is accumulating, technical methods are improving, and the organization of productive establishments is perfecting itself; while over against these changes in industry is an evolution in the wants of the individual consumer, whom industry has to serve. The nature, the causes, and the effects of these changes are among the subjects treated in this volume. The Political Economy of the century following the publication of the "Wealth of Nations" dealt more with static problems than with dynamic ones. It sought to obtain laws which fixed the "natural" prices of goods and those which, in a like way, governed the natural wages of labor and the interest on capital. This term natural as thus used, was equivalent to static. If the laws of value, wages, and interest had at this time been correctly stated, they would have furnished standards to which, in the absence of all change and disturbance, actual values, wages, and interest would ultimately have conformed. The economic theory of this time succeeded in formulating, correctly or otherwise, principles of economic statics and a fragment or two of a science of economic dynamics, although the distinction between the two divisions of the science was not clearly before the writers' eyes. The law of population contained in the work of Malthus is the only systematic statement then made of a general law of economic change. Though histories of wages, prices, etc., furnished some material for a science of Economic Dynamics, none of them attained the dignity of a presentation of law or merited a place in Economic Theory. Students of Political Economy were at that date scarcely awakened to the perception of laws of dynamics, and still less were they conscious of the need of a systematic statement of them. A modest beginning in the way of formulating such laws the present work endeavors to make. The first fact which becomes apparent when economic progress is studied, is that static laws have a general application and are as efficient in a society which is undergoing rapid transformation as in one that is altogether changeless. Water in a tranquil pool is affected by static forces. Let a quantity of other water rush in and there are superinduced on these forces others which are highly dynamic. The original forces are as strongly operative as ever, and if the inflow were to stop, would again reduce the surface to a level. The laws of hydrostatics affect the waters in the rapids of Niagara as truly as they do those in a tranquil pool; but in the rapids a further set of forces is also operative. In the work referred to, issued in 1899, an effort was made to isolate the phenomena of Economic Statics and to attain the laws which govern them. Necessarily this study made a certain impression of unreality, since it put out of sight changes which are actually going on and are the conspicuous fact of modern life. It assumed the conditions of a world without any such movement and endeavored to formulate laws which, in such a condition, would fix standards of value, wages, interest, etc. It put actual changes out of sight, intentionally and heroically, but with a full recognition of the fact that they are actually taking place and must in due time be introduced and studied. We live in what is par excellence  an age of progress, and it is in part for the sake of perceiving the laws of progress that we first disentangle from them the laws of rest and make a separate study of these. The world from which change is excluded is unreal, but the static laws which can be most clearly discerned by mentally creating such a world have reality. Every day's transactions are governed by them as truly as a physical element like water in active movement is affected by forces which, if they acted alone, would bring it to a state of permanent rest. The first purpose, therefore, of the present work is to show the presence and dominance in the real world of the forces described in the earlier work. It brings static laws into view and endeavors to show how they act at any one particular stage of industrial evolution. Even while changes are examined, the fact is perceived that there are steadily at work forces which, if changes should cease, would make society conform to a certain imaginary static model and makes wages and interest also conform to static standards. Another purpose of the work is to examine seriatim the effects of different changes, to gauge the probability of their continuance, and to determine the resultant of all of them acting together. It is important to know under what conditions changes proceed at a normal rate, and when the standard of wages rises as it naturally should. As the actual rate of wages pursues its rising standard, but lags somewhat behind it, it is necessary to know what determines the interval between the two, and when the interval is normal. What is called "economic friction" is the cause of this interval and is an element that is amenable to law. There is to be studied, not only the friction which obstructs the action of natural forces, but positive perversions of the forces themselves. Of these the chief is monopoly; and its influence, its growth, the sources of its power, and its prospect of continuance have to be determined. The actual tendencies of the economic system are against it, and so—if we except a few monopolies created for special ends—are both the spirit and the letter of the civil law. In a country in which law held complete sway, all objectionable monopolies would be held in repression. In order to see how much economic forces can be made to do in this direction, the present work discusses railroads and their charges, and some of the practices of great industrial corporations, and tries to determine what type of measures a government should take in dealing with these powerful agents. In connection with monopoly and with the conditions of economic progress a study is made of trade unions, strikes, boycotts, and the arbitration of disputes between employers and employed, and also of the policy of the state in connection with them, and with money and protective duties. It is my belief that students should become acquainted with the laws of Economic Dynamics, and that they can approach the study of them advantageously only after a study of Economic Statics. The present work is in a form which, as is hoped, will make it available for use in class rooms, not as a substitute for elementary text-books, but as supplementary to them. It omits a large part of what such books contain, presents what they do not contain, and tries to be of service to those who wish for more than a single introductory volume can offer. An essential part of the theory of wages here stated was presented in a paper read before the American Economic Association, in December, 1888, and published in a monograph of the American Economic Association in March, 1889; and other parts of this theory were issued at intervals following that date. The theory of value was published in the New Englander not then chanced to see the earlyfor July, 1881. I had statements of the principle of marginal appraisal contained in the works of Von Thünen and Jevons, and did not consciously borrow anything from their writings, but I gladly render to them the credit that is their due. I do not fear that I shall be supposed to have borrowed other parts of the general theory here offered. The theory of capital here stated was first presented in a monograph of the American Economic Association for May, 1888, and the discussion of money of which the present work gives a summary, in articles in the Political Science Quarterly for September, 1895, and for June and September, 1896. The discussion of the relation of protective duties to monopoly appeared in the same quarterly for September, 1904. The author should, perhaps, apologize for the fewness of the citations from other works which this volume contains. The richness of the recent literature of Economic Theory, especially in America, would have made it necessary to use much space if the resemblances and the contrasts presented by points in this volume, and corresponding points in other volumes, had been noted.

[Pg v]

[Pg vi]

[Pg vii]

[Pg viii]

[Pg ix]

[Pg x]

ityfi  tsaw  eahve seen it eitheni r  eht wart ro fheisind heatst dno sia  eom fhtf crde ong ieatiw dna ,tb evah eleabn eeenido  t useful. ke them ah d arpeWh va eowkndgletiacl ca aew  htl fo e tahw mate  theningncer ht eci h shwirla ansaintcoh rteaam ot yaw eht dn  risulegedatan, us rp hcudor stcailor or baker s doh w aomednrt  abh uc me tht ou ton evasa nwonk rn mmodet foarke niw aw yt ehihhc ekatolc ti m oten to leab net s ed ct .eWh f oo,de  preparehing, to  ,si robal tahw wnno kvehae  We.spi h lehwtana deds roceit phow   eht eroeht dnim en gremoac faler  eiwd no tifhtuobrinrst  befgingicosf lastcaub ;tht  cisnoanbet otg tea  nnuedsrtanding of such  dytu sofe osrppusi scimonocE gnitooland als teriia nehm dnt ,sa d anovprs oym hitiw am hsedimih  ins withhares ga hw omelp t ehm na  faceraloncets citevirimg nea dn udStf  o  phe—T y.rutaN ehredrO laFacts First in t isgni .t eGenar l crr tiea ang und ni ivicezilof—d lsaw le esal fiizedivil uncy—inrassecen syawla eart ha testiviti fht ecafla dno lth itsee of wean tnrutani eerehinrnthg  ctsceon noh mi etat  mhtuld e woncomis ilohw ton ,dnepedtilares hin  olyetirla an not  oam t partlyture, bualernoit no  sihmer  An.o  theot y mostud busdern sednisesg .laniur oenEvr teun hat dluow trap ekin a social econmo yfih  eebag n stol s el e om hofg si;emadna orf  Fal taenamndFu h.tlaew gniruces f  andLifeive imit orPnot oCmmtc s s onicwhree tila efiL hT— .coS  lai er in ci  each oth tsia not hem nus mag sih  dluow emad oo gor fetrkaeet erg optr ts mi  to comef thbe o m a ekraof tna rceano  tm;hind as coai lemhtdoo ything implies a  si tahtna ,ti dcae  mrehi w wchi  nhwciniudtsyr engagedh we are f a dah evah ew acsftisas es lar tsnadnreotu so t ntlyrecetil  d. Un he tor froegd unt nis ehneico ecvilized industrya ert rhwo nniot iIt ]   [1 gaorn  s ays dezin fo mets cialf So"Pol or la "ticimo.ycEno ve produ primititc ssaa  nerela af suf  gch hve oadw naah eehtoht—r n coatioformh inm culp,exemaof r, ad hvehae  Ww.onk ot sdeen rec tsyrt—ah tsi ,fo element in induo gnht fos elaicrytond usterdian ia nustsca hote cingrodulth  weaw nem tap era ohlaree thths onti h sab cec patilalth when ue of weareroah snehwbal x led ane ommpco alswar legenia ncert by rnedgovert si tahw gninitaersc arefoBe.  ring many finishrpdocu tna desucgeanor ft, it  ig desdoo ni hcxe s, elistprodach cemoevb ceai eps rtpar lae onf  o no gnicu ucitrap e eythpp a talt has llegat raea niilizatios of civ utero  f .n hT eaN teta stol el wis taler stcaf emos  h whealtto wing nereosg ra eci h  tI t sis ehetatf  oinbe"wg l o el ff",o  rfoh vanig one's wants am — .htlaeW  dlo ehTh isglEn ea   w rdwocsir  l ed aoceb sion nditife.of l eicsnoc sih ,tneamermptes hi, thehlao  fatets's  man  on a gely lared ydnepret am mofe he td oanssei  n arbllb-iegnlied. Weply supp s ndpede phe tontlaew fo tahT .h as ibedate a stsin er dserctod  thl  iatsos  cuse ;sdntub eht aew tion to his friecn,eo  rih seral hich h , w ealt rm  w isngll yigano ir oanthm he tofe et ehT .nem rehtand the   things, h sam roirhcm na ofn se useosiossetamlair luf dna i  ta dnuh ssit  thethatm is tergniht eh hcihw s m akemah,ic ranetwrrasdc ma eot be applied to t eifiht dts e eta be of g inchriaf,   ,niihhcordaa b  g inrninry, w dust  gnitaertlaew fo, seen s che tiswo nebofert ehs h, need to be knforpbatib yl uts eiaocfal s ctn ca  pri thet ofementsta d a ;naiddeho smynoco EalictiloP fo selpicnresentingin by pfero eeblu dhtre ins pedehi w icht fohtur  a gydob oft enndicitol pos dna s ygoloicso gand al tenertii ah tults sliteraevd  ienthn s talpmi o tse la fl conditions, inw ihhcn  oamkrtereve dna stsixe  hbys keman may a llbaronwl sio hat ds t goo the  ehTlaew u eh.ses usCr, oe otha f  aosilathttao  fmau, andry Esquiw sa a lle ht so ta icfrhaa  lves awi  nqeauotirlaA  that of a pygmy auq ehT i seitilon borr r.deoldhcinamAreoleye pmEurof a  or pean he tel wmorongtif tnp ropmi t atro are of iake a shw ihhcm  namttre ieitodmmcot esplmis eht ni detce detn ber caessoopssti so  fafer ds of industrialp orudtc saheva  ths  aat an re heywu er.desllA nik t tol acer igeth ni gm n kacr h aib n moom c. inigorna robaLatipac d t arsntaudicgna iner; anlantic lurt a ylonacsa eino ro pths  dey egtnowa est t ehere rywh eves is evitcudorp eht d of cheaf  oerow p

[Pg 1]

[Pg xiv]

[Pg 3]

[Pg 2]

[Pg 5]

[Pg 4]

[Pg xi] [Pg xii] [Pg xiii]

.i  nsudecseiht eof Ence micscono orked ino have w arug,e hw es rfoP on vie WedrichrissefF rodna orP try,counhis of tet rF te k.ArFnad an, enttPa.  NnomiS ,rehsiF gni frPfoseossrI vrn the writings oow , dluevaheeb has bed  genenivi  foi,nitnoicateciaf sptentl ato yhtroW ot deht erewiap Haf eydlor w oks.yI  femsaet dawtention rited at ni semeht emas e tron y c glontr s a srt oah ,hwneanf thme od soeateerstug E ven Bon-mhöewaBo kriV f ed belong, and asl ohtso o e  fiMin icwhn  iste thh eh seidureffo erious varts o par eas fhteidlemf  O RIGITS   I.V A IN 1 I W. AE GA I E NA   DTL   H S C NTTEON   PERPTHA SETAB NH C .KRALC  NSUMERS ' W EALTH 3 EH M  AEUSERO    FO C C   MIOD G O 0 I S 2 .TII TEIR   SEI E  FOONOC os J rfose ,rPoisngest sugablevalu gnireffo dna tpriscnumae thg in rpoo.f OJ o  fht e readingself thenopumih at y nek kasdlinnsoh hon I 721 SEGA A L  EH T.X NT  I OFW  46 T 1 ESER 9 S V 2 OCEM ROAM IIN. LUE 1 L  V A II.W 14 VI TSN I EMUR 1 STN IX 47 E C I. OMON  D ICAMYN .X E R TN 51 X 9 .I A L DN   AND  A RTIFICIAL   N   IOCTDURO .P 9 V Y 5 SI D ; SISEHTNY S  A ALIZ S OCI T HE   9 IV. SURT I  DN   NFOTAOI LA R EONTID   ANS   ITNEREN I  T   OT   FFI D N   AN  A NATRIBUTIO .I A V UL   E YLIS 7 S V 4 e  o busthre pptëm  kooluowah dt ev  gratefully to a de I . d seri eomtsnctaisssh icwhe delwonkca eht egf thon oook is behp nit ariterap ,namdiG S ,rgile Cg,vearTa, sius  d aohtsklre ,naager, Wa dings, Se a ,sralohcs ngirefot eninemf  oehb nit ca e epsf thrt oe palarg nomoci sniC lomubia University,  dnamorf ym mrof cerleolueagPr, os rfose .oJ.AS n ofhnso Univ  the o ytisresarbeN fsiBe. kaadres de eceived f I have r loelgaeuor mymc r so LH.Pr, esofC fomulooM . eroty, ersiUnivbia M .ros,nm  yrfmoCle icurMan oh J cE ni wolleF ,kra XXX.S UMMARY   OF  C ECNRNI   GO M EN 5 Y 83  5EX ES 63 NTSELSIA LCNOOISU 55 SN DNI 5 ECTI P ROTND  M ON   A ST 05 DOCU II.IX 3 VX  F NGDIEAON   CTSAC 5 YLOPONO L.XIXX 71 noa dnt  ercaeit ORIGIN Th AND ITS  hwyr ereera eve wef thal uhe ose  SFOITLASSNE RO E Y THEOMICECON OF   HTLAEW I RETPAHC RYEOTHC MINOCO E ROPSITAT 93 NO IXX 6 T H V.F OE   GOREG   INR P NIICLPSEA   PPILED   TO   THE  R AILRO   SECRO F  RGOR P  FO XX 72 S 3 ES NE G E I.II C E NOAR   L L  WAMOCIFECTS   AF T RANING   BYD   RB  A S    AXEFI X 074 IIVX ARTINOIT S   AND   TH .B OYCOTTGNO    FR P  EI L IMIT XV 6 X 41 EMBLRO  P AD FO   NOITAZINAGR O. I.T H 1 XXV OR 45 L AB GASEFO W  IS   S   EA B 32 ONTILA E  T H X. 1 X WA L  EH T. UPO P  FO   M ETH   OF  1 XIX OD 30  DYBCEETGNSE C  AH C A I. TAPIASL   FF   A H C  CEGNA 282 S IIVX TAILED   BY  D YNAMIHT   EA H DRHSPI   SNE EHT   TREVREP   HCIH   WESNCUEFL I N I.XI 53 X 8 ITNOINAZR O AGAND   HOD   M ETS   INOR P  SERGUSNIGNIRTIDIS   ON XI 9 X ON .C PATILA 33 OI   NFO C  CCUMULAT L AW   OF  A C E NOET   D S  COMOCI 229 X IETY RPET V.P E N I  CIMANSECNEULFN   HIIT   WMI L IE   TH MOCI S  COEIYT 12 X 0 IV.E FFECTS   OF  D Y 1 SCI IX 59 T.IIL  EHITIMOFS   N    AON E C UENC I NFLHER  F URTCU   ER   DEIHHCSEW   P RF    ODSHOET  M IN .IIVX 652 NOITCUDO .E FFECT   RE 244 XVI EVEMTN   SFO I  PMOR   OGETHF   L   UAAN C HRT S  UTCUO S  ELAIC th. weal of singdnu gna aeit arc ngnierov s g aw lhet fo tnemetats A such a my which ecssseb t ehp oro  tm hi ythldieeht rae m nasekac moa dn owlu oftrs ofmeanport sup o ecneiccE eht ftinscod  S atetu diLef ,hwci hsionomy of IsolatereneS laneico ec p at ar tof ghe  htlaew etaerc dt bu; ite usd ant kan touodlehw socin a rt ie pai fosudnk la dnihet  esdo y.trha W tob  eedc uodln as a bitscribed oc"sf  o"n" l,ia,lanoitaop" ro "cal"litinomy eco tht .eYnini eagofg is hiv lg w in dluo eb e naonocmic operation an dowlu dniovvl e an ce  bg inatthos ehtemtsumvah o lives y man wh la.l vEre owkra  t hietom o s  dstmue h ,mih ot nevig t isss iunlend, ,ha aetldew acll  ni ac a ,evitaehuy erntli, ngvitei .tA s lotirang in order to g iks riehluow ,sn im hnghi  tin lfsela snamilctona dhe fng t of lesh idcsvorese,ea  s ated, co ed and st  yb utanevogdenran, thd l rawsla eh mfot mo e.sS erato op intcomeics eht etutitsnicomonEcf  oceen  less civilized osicteei sna dow n iolyonhe wmen il ni evom n ro er  arehersrati opeeherevw em nev rann  irkizanrg o ,yaw deto elihw rtain co re are cew ihhcm dntioisn it,hef t usisex evillew si l ot ich n whay iin wee,drpcosu tehm velil il whef  ieht dna ,lla ta   esiw ah tehi  sand because natursi eahw ti t si erthise  c ataer ru en taht ena dactechar hisr ofairetam orivne l Bt.ennm hseauec jbus tcefles si or fim hs rklyon h sio nwabes dno that are  to laws  monocE lareneG f oldie Fhe . T alit  oow nhw aamo  fnomy eco—The ics. e  bd,hand auc sag ni emon sot tther form of cap h atsro esia on d w oo fgh ren hiit k lliw euone pee  perover wheiodsott ca hih mdi e essspoe  hif, erh ,thgiserof ses, oralth e  we ctiv ervo .oMtilac pa ha c ar seofs he t p  fo udor of e smr  the prirer; forpmelemtnimitevi ipac a ,a tsilat allwes bolaa s  mot ot ihmo,eb cea si in  waymple yas  gnitaht ti  aisadn ntvae agb woa dna rrwo.s This amounts toroa ae r apska eto mugh  enolong gnitnuh sih tpurernt iton maa h apsys cutn.sI  t implemeing suchni ekam sih mit om sofe t noeduse if e donhad  he  ehw ah nh vauodlor mtsge tmegae emelpmi  eh ,stn hunts with gooda  nsilotadem na vetiap Calit If . — ocE f imon P .sc imir tionrelaat ds thertnfief es slcsa sen mof tintauso hcae oew ,reht enter the realmo  f oSicla E oconcsmian; wed o  dsihtehw evenew r  sfoilgnd ae rfoss o cla one any to yna htiw nem f ofd elFie Th r.he cEnomociS coai l oment th s. —The m nige otw taeb enococ mimixa ene p tnereh fo rewoterastluine ths yab ewm  rrf eaftal,capiugh  tho rednna sob dworrth om kiin onglef m"noyem raek"to ers in a modern  he tofk easpe  wnehW .niamod tah and bowin ades erisah tret p woh ut Ge ofo  ttra r ewreferra  ,wo which iland one nomoci s enar   l cE  oin So f  alci co Eymonub ;ew tnac  ns takes us at oneci tn oht eodamh ltea wt a outhwi ne lla tt gniret dy c stuin uertasrlainev sfol wa ,robtiw hw ,al oclr s,asanh heot ilgn sfot ehd ae s of men  one clasyduts ehT .htlaeioatel rchsuf  ooctno  ro nww ohve wuctiprodrol   yacllt ehr leta n what we commonl  yawetnitseri det bu iheins o  n ya sa wlsestusggt ex thasionpresatipac decnis ,lf  onsioanr bola s of vit capital i a dno  ffol baropoe r weduroivcterehp tnhT .ni e st; talicapid a  rnaober aalto h bise  hcein sm,ih ot nrecnoc la