Hiding the World in the World

Scott Cook

Description

A literary and philosophical masterpiece of its age, and yet one of the most puzzling and elusive texts ever written, the Zhuangzi has been continuously reinterpreted. Here the age-old hermeneutic project of reading the Zhuangzi is brought up to the present with new essays addressing an array of interrelated topics from a variety of perspectives. These include how the work stands in relation to such issues as mystical experience, "skeptical" and "relativist" attitudes, individual value, ethical orientation, folk psychologies and popular beliefs, and rhetorical logic and structure. By providing ten "uneven" perspectives on such matters, this volume contributes to the ongoing discourse on Zhuangzi's philosophy by placing it within our present interpretive context and pushing that context to new limits.

Acknowledgments

A Note on Conventions

Introduction
Scott Cook

1. Bimodal Mystical Experience in the "Qiwulun" Chapter of the Zhuangzi
Harold D. Roth

2. How Many Are the Ten Thousand Things and I? Relativism, Mysticism, and the Privileging of Oneness in the "Inner Chapters"
Brook Ziporyn

3. Harmony and Cacophony in the Panpipes of Heaven
Scott Cook

4. From "Merging the Body with the Mind" to "Wandering in Unitary Qi ": A Discussion of Zhuangzi's Realm of the True Man and Its Corporeal Basis
Rur-Bin Yang

5. Guru or Skeptic? Relativistic Skepticism in the Zhuangzi
Chad Hansen

6. Aporetics Ethics in the Zhuangzi
Dan Lusthaus

7. Reflex and Reflectivity: Wuwei in the Zhuangzi
Alan Fox

8. A Mind-Body Problem in the Zhuangzi?
Paul Rakita Goldin

9. "Nothing Can Overcome Heaven": The Notion of Spirit in the Zhuangzi
Michael J. Puett

10. Transforming the Dao: A Critique of A. C. Graham's Translation of the Inner Chapters of the Zhuangzi
Shuen-Fu Lin

References to Works on the Zhuangzi

List of Contributors

Index of Zhuangzi Citations

Index

Sujets

• Lycée
• Philosophie
• Taoism

Informations

• Publié par: State University of New York Press
• Date de parution: 25 septembre 2003
• Nombre de lectures: 1
• EAN13: 9780791486184
• Langue: English
• Poids de l'ouvrage: 4 Mo

Extrait

,17+(:
25/'
+,',1*7+(: 25/';=6A[MZ
QM[QV+PQVM[M8PQTW[WXP
aIVL+]T\]Z
M
:W
OMZ
<


)UM[
MLQ\WZ-LQ\MLJ
W
7+(:
25/'
=VM
^
MV,Q[KW]Z
[M[WV\PM
BP]IVObQ
V
a
RUNSUHVV DW HXQLY VLW\RIQH HU Z\
VFRWWFRRN
+,',1*7+(: 25/',1
_Q\PW]\\PMXZ
UQ[[QWV
QTaV8
1VKT]LM[JQJ
MXZ
W\\
A
)TJIV
QM
YOF#ONG

UMKPIVQKIT
1;*6w!w wITS
MZ
a
^

M[[
!;\I\M;\Z
aJM[\WZ

M[MZ
M\QVOJ
aNWZ
INGIN0UB
[M[WV\PMBP]IVO

aIVLK]T\]Z
6WXIZ
MNMZ
MKWZ
ITS
A
6IVP]IRQVO
aUIVVMZ_P

6M
QM[
_Q\PW]\_Z

MZ

\WN
;]Q\M
)TTZ

QVIZ
WL]K\QWVJ
)TJIV
;MUMZIL
IT[a[\MU
W
ML
ESS#ATALO
aIV
0QLQVO\PM_
^
MTMK\Z
a;KW\\+WWS
)UMZ
x;=6A[MZ
UIOVM\QK\IXM

;\I\M=VQ
O
aQVO

\PQ[JWWSUI
"
WZW\PMZ_Q[

^

WL]KMLQVIV

[Q\aWN
+PQVM[M
I\[WM
+WWS
WZS8Z
11
MZ
*4!+0
_

Q\\MVXMZ
!
a

6WXIZ
M[[
WZS
MM\
\PQ[JWWSUI


a
ML
6A
QOP\[Z
8Z
M\Z
a5IZ
[Q\aWN

^
5IZS
^
a5QKPIMT+IUXWKPQIZ
WZ\ZIV[UQ\\MLQVIV
,IBRAR
a
R
UWZJ
G
8Z
LICATION$ATA
aUMIV[QVKT]LQVOMTMK\Z
WZTLQV\PM_
]VM

MVLQ[KW]Z

bQMLQ\MLJ
W[\I\QK


KU

QM[QV+PQVM[MXPQTW[WXP
QKI
M


_
TQW
XPW\WKWX
ZIXPQKITZ
\WN
MVKM[IVLQVLM`
Z

^
XIXMZx1;*6w!w wXJS
LQVO

aJM][MLWZZ
XIXMZ
M

BP]IVObQ
TQ[PMLJ
;\I\M=VQ
6M
‰
QV\MLQV\PM=VQ\ML;\I\M[WN
WVQK
WZTL"
QWZXMZ

UQ[[QWVQV_Z
8PQTW[WXP
Q\QVOWN

\PMX]J

TQ[PMZ
1

;K
.

WZQVNWZ
;MZ
UI\QWV

ILLZ

M[[;\I\M=VQ
!! xLK
^

MZ

[Q\aWN

6M

_

A

WZS8Z
8]J
X
IVXQXM[WN




«]*Ö
`
QVOQV=VQ\IZ
5QÎ)Ä
XWZ
.Q
/]Z
0IZ
^Q[\QK;S




QVO\PM*WLa_Q\P\PM5QVLu
QMVKMQV\PM
Ž
1V\Z
<
+PIX\MZWN
7VMVM[[
^
$œ
ˆ

MX\QKQ[UQV
MM
D
aIVL+IKWXPWV
MV\QWV[
^
<
_
BP]IVObQ
G
7VM
.

WU
*QUWLIT5a[\QKIT-`XMZ
t?

9Q
t9Q_]T]V

^QQ
[:MITUWN
MX\QK':MTI\Q
]M5IVIVL1\[
WL]K\QWV
QVOWN
\PM
QV\PM
[u

D
D

]WZ;S

)6W\MWV+WV^
<PZ


D
UWV
M
aQV\PM8
SVW_TMLOUMV\[
0MI

MV

D
D
#ONTENTS
)K

\PM
BP]IVObQ
t1VVMZ+PIX\MZ
W
1°ë"Y


0W
W]Z
_5IV
.Z
a
t5MZO
)Z
\W
M\PM
IVLMZ
<
a
MV

<PW][IVL
u"
<PQVO[IVL1'
),Q[K][[QWVWN
:MTI\Q
BP]IVObQs
^Q[U
\PM
5a[\QKQ[U
Z
IVL\PM8Z
+WZ
Q
MIT*I[Q[
^QTMO

ö¢‡

Q
H8 II8 D@
=6G DA99G I=
7G D@O>EDGNC
H8 II8 D@
JG7>CN6C<
8=69=6CH:C
u!
ZIV[TI\QWVWN
QV\PM
Q\QV\PM
Q\QY]MWN
?


MVu"
M
]\WZ[
UQVO\PM,IW"
^Q\a"


\PM

?
9
KWUM0MI
+Q\I\QWV[
<PM6W\QWVWN
^
!


<
)5QVL*WLa8Z


)

[
BP]IVObQ
1VVMZ+PIX\MZ
]_MQ
QJ


Å
BP]IVObQ
)XWZ
4Q[\WN
BP]IVObQ
^
;M

BP]IVObQ
;XQZ
1VLM`


®¡

MV


<


ZIV[NWZ
:MäM`IVL:MäMK\Q
)+Z

M\QK[-\PQK[QV\PM


-QOP\
MV
WJ

TMUQV\PM
+
BP]IVObQ
/ZIPIUs
'
<
E
\PM
6
[WN

BP]IVObQ
1VLM`WN
š1o!



:MNMZMVKM[\W

WZS[WV\PM
6QVM



t6W\PQVO+IV7^
+WV\Z
MZ

BP]IVObQ
;Q`
6CAJH I=6JH
6A6C;D
JAG 6@>I6<DA9>C
B>8=6:A?EJ: II
H=J:C;JA>C

KWUXTM`
IXXMIZ
)
NWZ
aTWZ

\W
4QV
IXXMIZ
;WKQM\a

\PM
[WV
0WVO

\IVLN
Q[
UIV
][
^
\PM
0IZ
WPV
+PQVM[M
\PM
^QLML
MXZ


WT]UM
<b]
IVL
Z


BQs

_
xX]J
O

\PZ
[
_
\PM
_
)[QIV
<PMU
!CKNO
I[


2W]Z
5IRWZ

KPQMN
KWUUMV\[
<
J
XMZ
;M
UQVO
MZ

[
<

WN
QVO
J
XIVMT
QV

a
QV
VW[
WZ

MV\Q\TML
)TIV
^
BP]IVObQ
t9Q_]T]V
[_
_

^

\PQ[
WVI\PIV

\PM
JM\\MZ
XMZ
\PI\
MXZ
MZ
a
PMTL
a
M

M
_PQKP
[MZ
J
NWZ
,
IVL

WZ
QV

WN
P

\PM

+PQVOKPQP

MLQ\WZ
VIU
3
XZ
`


LQ[K][[IV\
\W
[QVOTM
t<
MV
,IW"

Q\QY]M
\MV


/ZIPIUs
\PQ[
WN
^Q[U
+PIX\MZ
M
\PM
M
u
XZ
;P]MVN]
^
IXXMIZ
ãZ
[\
1TT]UQVI\QWV
9]IZ
WVM
"R*?
–ä

WVO
\M`\[#

BP]IVO

aV
<
WT]UM
W
WN
J
[
]_MQ
LMZN]T
KW
?PW
MJ[Q\MKIVJMNW]VLI\P\\X"___
W
TQ[PMZs
5QÎ)Ä
!w
IV
"
<PM

UW[\
VIT["
u
2
W]OP
0MZ
Q\
IVL
\PQVS
MLQ\WZ
\PI\
NWZ
\W
UQ[[QWV
Z
Z
PMTXML
QV\
I[
M[[I

WT
:W][M[

^
8PQTW[WXP
I\
QV
;P]MVN]
ML
I\QWV

NWZ

)[[WKQI\QWV

^QVO
a
.
WTL
KPIQZ


:W\P
2
_PQKP
_
ML
;
<PM

VIT


\P"
:MTQOQWV[
NWZ


"
UIV
w#
4Q]
QV[QOP\

M

N]T
I\
5a[\QKQ[U
0WVS
PM
WVO
a
Z
W
\QWV
WN
4QUQ\ML
I[
NWZ
W]\
UQ[[QWV

Z
8
QV\
^
ZIV[NWZ
\W
\PM
WN

\PQ[
+Z
\PM
WN
M
)
KPIX\MZ
+
[XMK\Q

QV
[
TQS
ZIV[TI\QWV
^

I
1VVMZ
IZ
[
[PW]TL

IXXMIZ
+P]IVO


QV

_
a
QV\
4QV
UW\Q
_PQKP
\PM
ML
XMZ
<
IV[TI\QWV
^QQ
QVQ\QIT
NWZ
W]\


a

\QUM
\MZT




?
3
M

_

W]TL
IVL
TQS
!!!"
M
w!#
\W
IVL
\PIVS
I
PI[
IVL
a
.
^
a
a

^
?
?
u
]S

Z
WLEDGMENTS

)[QIV ;\]LQM[s NWZ \aVQV\P ]IT )VV 5MM\QVO QV +PQKIOW WV KP 5IZ
IV[TI
WVM_PW MZ WVMIVLM MTaIV M\W\PIVS QVKT][Q M[PW]TLIT[WTQS
W_M^MZ
L V
QV\PM QV\ t:MäM`IVL:MäMK\Q ^Q\a" UQ[[QWV\WZ MXZ .ZIVKQ[NWZXMZ
u BP]IVObQ t*QUWLIT 5a[\QKIT QMVKM-`XMZ QV \PM r9Q_]T]Vs +PIX\MZ \PMWN
\PM NWTTW _QVO NWZ UQ[[QWVXMZ \W QV\ MXZ KPIX\MZ[ \PI\ [\ãZ IXXMIZ ML QV RW]Z
QV \PQ[ WT]UM MZ M ITT [\ ãZ XZ M[MV\ML I[ [ XIXMZ WV \PI\ WKKI[Q WV# M \PIVS
!! [J <PMKPIX\MZ a;KW\\+WWS 0IZ WTL, :W\P IVL*Z WWSBQX\PQ[
OMZ


UMV\WZ
\PM
ITT
=VQ
—Öm
\W
\PIVS
^
ZIXP
UI\\MZ
A

8Z
Z
IVWV
IVL
\PIVS[
PI
MZ
UM
5QVOPIW
4QV
TWVO
_PW[M
I[
6M
BP]IVObQ
O

NWZ

WZS

;\I\M
MVKW]ZIOMUMV\
M[[
L
_TMLOUMV\[
WT]UM#
;XMKQIT
IVO
^
^
OW

aUW][
TM\
5I
IT[W
[Q\a
;P]MVN]
28.o
KMWN
PI[

[MZ

ML
KITTQO
I
MILMZ
WV
a

_
[#
ZIKM[
:W
\PM
<
KW
)UM[
)KSVW
Q[
Z
WN

_PW
^
NWZ
MZ
PQ[
WN
QV

MOIZ
\PQ[
\W
JWWS
^


7V
?
I
;P]UQV
XMZ
MJMMVIKWV[\IV\IVLJW]VLTM[[[W]Z
[WVIT
Z
TM

^

MT
I

QV[XQZI\QWV

^QQQ
_PW[M QOWZ LMLQKI\QWV IVL MV\P][QI[U I[ JW\P I [KPWTIZ IVL OMV\TMUIV
?Z

WU
[Q\a8Z
Z
BP]IVObQ
!
KQ\ML
\Z
<PM
IZ
M`KMX\
]UJMZ
!
Z
IVO@QIW
\PM

IT[W
!
O
!.OTEON#ON
]UJMZ
WN
W]OPW]\"
MIZTQMZ
KWV
IVL
WZS[
BP]IVObQ
8]J
/]W
IV
Q\[MTN

QV
ML#
\PM
/ZIPIU


\PM

Q[
?
JW\P
?
I[
WZS"


^QI\QWV[IZ
M\IQVML
\PM
U[
^
_
PI
KWVKWZ
\W
WV
WN
XIOM
\PM
BP]IVObQ
+PMVO_
WN
V

BB2;%
IVs
!\PK
WVTa

#

MVKM[
—
“3=
KI[M[
BPWVOP]I[P]R]
J

\Q\TM
)
IZ

KPIX\MZ
MV
IKQTQ\I\M

\PM
/MWZOM
LQVO
?
MV
*]Z
[WUM

^
+P]IVO
KPIX\MZTQVM
_
MTT
^
\M`\
!
_QVOIJJZ

WN

a
M
UIRWZ
IVL
0A%
NZ
^
IZ
IZ
][QVO
/QTM[
MVKPQVO
M
QM[
MZ
LIVKM
aQV
\PM
\PM

[]KP
\PM
_PMZ
V
QO
VW\
QV\"
[
MV

TQ[PQVO+WUXIV




9QVON
/]W9QVON
ITT
-Wx&T
[

N
BP]IVObQRQ[PQ
RQ[PQ
$œ
ˆ0.
MNMZ
!

?

a]
UW[\

\W
*MQRQVO"


_Q\P

+PQVM[M
/ZIPIU%
\M`\

WN
+
]\
)VO][+PIZTM[
\PM
+P]IVO\b]"
M
<PM;M^
NZ
1VVMZ+PIX\MZ[IVL7\PMZ
<
Q\QVO[NZWU\PM*WWSWN
_PQKP
+P]IVO\b]
IKKWZ
4WVLWV"
XI[[IOM
)TTMV=V_QV
_Q\P

\IS
I\[WV%
\W
I\[WV
Q[
\WV
+PQVM[M

Q
<PM+WUXTM\M
XIOM
WZS[WN
MV
<b]
WN
6M
_
A
V
+WT]UJQI=VQ

MZ
KWUXIZ
M[[
NWTTW

[
+PQVM[M
M
Z
\PM
6IUM[
MMUXTW
a

Z
ML\PZ

WN


\MZ
0IZ
Y]W\ML
0IZ
WU
\ZILQ\QWVIT
-VOTQ[PTIVO]IOM
WZS[
Q`
W
Q[WV

KWUUMV\IZ
LA
?
LA
\PM
MVKPQVO1V[\Q\]\M
ILM

[a[\MU

^
BP]IVObQaQVLM
JMMV

^
$œ
ˆç5
\ML
)
XQV
KWVKWZ

LIVKM\W+P]IVO
QV
<b]
\Q\TM[
*MQRQVO"


_
A

IVRQVOLI`]M\][P]
M
O]IVaQVLMJQIVb]IVR]
WZ
!<
QVIT
IQXMQZ
WUIVQbI\QWV[
MXZ
ENTIONS
a

5IQVTIVL XQVaQV WUIVQbI\QWV Q[ MLMUXTW \PZW]OPW]\# VIUM[

]TIV
]\WZ
NWZ
JWWS
\W
[]Z
M
\PM
IZ
Z
ZIXP

[MKWVLIZ
\PW[M
VIUM[
ILM/QTM[

^
PI
a
MZ
W]\[QLM
TQKI\QWV[

M
\PM
_PQKP
MVL
M`KMX\
XZ
IKKWZ
.]VO
O
)TT

M
PI
ãZ
[\W\PQ[^
\PW[M
[
[
\PMKWV\Z
M
^
M
KQ\ML
WZ
QV
-VOTQ[PTIVO]IOM
^
)TT
XQV
MVKM[
UIQVTIVL
J
\Q\TM#
QV
TQW

I\
KI[M

IT[W
ITT

a
NWZ

LQVO
A
[KPWTIZ

K][\WU
+PQVM[M
_PW
WT]UM
?
TQ[\ML
Q
VIUM
Q[
[\
^
M`KMX\
a
WN
^
[KPWTIZ
QJ
_PW
TQ
^

ILWX\ML
MV
Z
J
^
ML
[M
M
LMZ
IZ
\PMQZ
\PI\
X]J
WN


MNMZ
)6W\MWV+WV
MV\QWV[
M
aQV
+PQVI
I]\PWZ
BP]IVObQ
IZ
M
TQ[\ML
\PM
a
WV
IVL
WZS[

_
JQJ
I
O
XIZ
a
\QK]TIZ
\PM
[XMTTQVO
WN
NWZ
\PM
\PMQZ
TQ[\[
W
\PM
_V
QUIZ
VIUM[
IVL
QM
a


IZ
`
MUXTW ML QM +PsQMV 5]xWZ NWZ \PW[M _PW PI M XZ ^QW][Ta M[\ IJ TQ[PML][
^
KWUXTM\ML
][\
LZI
\PI\
IZ
Z
_V

MNNWZ
a
I

$œ
ˆ
OMVMZI\QWV[
LMMX

TI
\PMZ
\QVO
I
[\IVLIZ
JM
\PM
ãVL

D
Q\[MTN
ML
a
IVL
M
^
[\QU
\W
M
ML'
Z
MN]TTa
WVM
\PM
IVL

PMZ
LIZS
\W
VMOI\QVO
M\
a
Z
M
IZ
KTIZ
<

JMMV

[WZ

M[
\W
_
QVKM[[IV\


VMKM[[Q\a
VW
M\QVO

N]Z
_
_
KZ
VM
PI
M
XZ
M[[MV\QIT
][
UQTTMVVQI
\PMZ

\W
_
a
^
IZ
W]

\I[S
\PM
QV
_
WXMZTa

JMNWZ

VMOI\QWV[
M
OIQVML

I[[MZ
M
XW[M
W]Z
\PI\
[
WN
M
a
NWZ
0I
VWVM\PMTM[[
MILMZ
\PW[M
J
WVOWQVO
I[
\PI\
Q[
WKMML
M
XIZILW
M`XTIQVQVO
\PM
^
M
`
WL]K\QWV
\PM
^

a[
aN]TVM[[
^
W]Z
IT
M
QV\MZ
Z
WN
\PMZ
IN\MZ
Q\P
_Q\P
IVL
BP]IVObQ
WZS[
I[[MZ
NZIUM

WN
I]LQMVKM
^


MZ
M
\_

]T\QUI\M
[
Z

]\P[
WKMML
VW

\PM
a
^
U
Q\
LWVM

_Q\P
M[

I\
[W
\PM
WU
?PI\
\QUM
\PM

WXQVO
KWV\M`\
WN

a
Q[
XZ
a[
\PM
\I[S
I[[MZ
\QK]TIZ
X]Z
W]Z
ITT
][

UIS
IVL
[]KP
M
KTIQU
ITT
A
\P