Language, Ontology, and Political Philosophy in China

Rudolf G. Wagner

Description

With the collapse of the Han dynasty in 220 C.E., an entire system of state and intellectual organization fell apart. The brilliant Wang Bi and his generation of young scholars grew up in a no-man's land without teachers and orthodoxy. Defying the established school divisions, they set out on a vigorous and daring new philosophical inquiry which came to be known as Xuanxue, the "Scholarly Exploration of the Dark." They found "subtle pointers" in the Laozi, the Book of Changes, and the Analects of Confucius about the inequity of language and the ensuing need to proceed by "subtle" indications that ultimately led to a philosophy of Being.

In this book, Rudolf G. Wagner shows how Wang Bi's sophisticated analysis of "subtle pointers" in the language of the Laozi developed into an ontology that served as the basis for a political philosophy of the ruler/subject relationship and a guide for the public performance of an enlightened ruler. Wang Bi's work initiated the reading of the Laozi, the Book of Changes and the Analects as philosophical texts and has had a lasting impact on Chinese philosophy.

Preface

Introduction

1. Discerning the That-by-Which: The Language of the Laozi and the Lunyu

A Plea for a History of Understanding
The Consensus: The Ineffability of the Sage’s Thinking
The Radical Position
Developing Reading Strategies
The Discussion about Language and the Thinking of the Sage in Wei
The Structural Contradiction of the Confucius Texts: Talking about That-Which-Is-Dark
The Logical Deduction of the Unnameability of That-by-Which the Ten Thousand Kinds of Entities Are
The Deduction of the Possibility of Limited but Sufficiently Grounded Propositions about That-by- Which the Ten Thousand Kinds of Entities Are
Traces of the That-by-Which Found by the Confucius Texts within the Structures of Discernible Entities: Antinomy and Negation
Grasping Aspects of the That-by-Which
An Explanation of the Images [Xiang of the Zhouyi]

2. Wang Bi’s Ontology

The Framework of Analysis
Wang Bi’s Inquiry into the That-by-Which
Wang Bi’s Approach
The Binary Structural Organization of Entities
The Order of the Ten Thousand Kinds of Entities
The One and the Many
The Dao
The Dark

3. Wang Bi’s Political Philosophy

The Actual and Perpetual Crisis of Human Society
The Causes of the Crisis
Operating the Return: The Sage
Sagely Politics as Public Performance
Wang Bi’s Philosophy: An Ideology?

Notes

Bibliography

Index

Sujets

• East Asian religions
• Taoism

Informations

• Publié par: State University of New York Press
• Date de parution: 09 janvier 2003
• Nombre de lectures: 0
• EAN13: 9780791488867
• Langue: English
• Poids de l'ouvrage: 1 Mo

Extrait

4IVO]IOM
7V\WTWOa

IVL
8WTQ\QKIT8PQTW[WXPa
QV+PQVI;=6A[MZQM[
QV
+PQVM[M8PQTW[WXPaIVL+]T\]ZM
,I^QL40ITTIVL:WOMZ<
)UM[MLQ\WZ[4IVO]IOM
7V\WTWOa

IVL
8WTQ\QKIT8PQTW[WXPa
QV+PQVI
?
IVO*Qs
[;KPWTIZTa-`XTWZI\QWV
WN\PM,IZS
@]IV`]M

;\I\M=VQ^MZ[Q\aWN6M_A
WZS8ZM[[
:]LWTN/?
IOVMZ

6A

11<
.WZQVNWZUI\QWVILLZM[[\PM;\I\M=VQ^MZ[Q\aWN6M_A

_Q\PW]\_ZQ\\MVXMZUQ[[QWV6WXIZ\WN\PQ[JWWSUIaJM[\WZML

-JCSBSZPG$POHSFTT$BUBMPHJOHJO1VCMJDBUJPO%BUB
5M\IXPa[QK[
Q\TM"?
_Q\PW]\\PMXZQWZXMZUQ[[QWVQV_ZQ\QVOWN\PMX]JTQ[PMZ
;MZQM[
6WXIZ\WN\PQ[JWWSUIaJM][MLWZZMXZWL]KMLQVIVaUIVVMZ_P
!


;\I\M=VQ^MZ[Q\aWN6M_A

8ZWL]K\QWVJa5QKPMIT0IOOM\\
1;*6w!wwITSXIXMZx1;*6w!wwXJS"
WZ\ZIV[UQ\\MLQVIVaNWZUWZJaIVaUMIV[QVKT]LQVOMTMK\ZWVQK
8PQTW[WXPa
IOVMZ
?
!
M
[[KPWTIZTaM`XTWZI\QWVWN\PMLIZS`]
8ZQV\MLQV\PM=VQ\ML;\I\M[WN)UMZQKI
111

*?


WZS8ZM[[
!
I\[WM^MZ

;\I\M=VQ^MZ[Q\a8TIbI)TJIVa
X
WZS8ZM[[)TJIVa


1VKT]LM[JQJTQWOZIXPQKITZMNMZMVKM[IVLQVLM`
QVIZM\ZQM^IT[a[\MU

5IZSM\QVOJa.ZIV3MVM[\WV
ITSXIXMZ
WZS

?
+PQVM[Mx*+w!),
MTMK\ZW[\I\QK

:]LWTN/

;\I\M=VQ^MZ[Q\aWN6M_A
‰
)TTZQOP\[ZM[MZ^ML
UIOVM\QK\IXMUMKPIVQKITXPW\WKWXaQVOZMKWZLQVOWZW\PMZ_Q[
IVO*Qw

1<

IVO*Qs
4IVO]IOMWV\WTWOa
IV`]M
IVLXWTQ\QKITXPQTW[WXPaQV+PQVI"?
Q\TM
IVO*

Qs

[[KPWTIZTa


wLK
M`XTWZI\QWVWN\PMLIZS

`]IV`]M

:]LWTN/?

IOVMZ






KUx;=6A[MZQM[QV+PQVM[MXPQTW[WXPaIVLK]T\]ZM
8]JTQ[PMLJa


<PM:ILQKIT8W[Q\QWV

_Q\PQV\PM;\Z]K\]ZM[WN,Q[KMZVQJTM-V\Q\QM[")V\QVWUaIVL
M`\["
8
-BP[J
IVO*Qs


ZIKM[WN\PM<PI\Ja?PQKP.W]VLJa\PM+WVN]KQ][<


<PM+WV[MV[]["<PM1VMNNIJQTQ\aWN\PM;IOMs
BPW]aQ






-VOZV


?PQKP\PM<

\PM<PQVSQVOWN\PM;IOMQV?








E
5IF-BOHVBHFPGUIF




IVO*Qs


BOEUIF
!
,M^MTWXQVO:MILQVO;\ZI\MOQM[
!

MV<PW][IVL3QVL[WN-V\Q\QM[

<PM7VMIVL\PM5IVa


<PM,Q[K][[QWVIJW]\4IVO]IOMIVL
MV<PW][IVL3QVL[WN-V\Q\QM[)ZM


<
)8TMINWZI0Q[\WZaWN=VLMZ[\IVLQVO
M`\[
MQ




6MOI\QWV


<PM;\Z]K\]ZIT+WV\ZILQK\QWVWN\PM+WVN]KQ][<
/ZI[XQVO)[XMK\[WN\PM<PI\Ja?PQKP
*OUSPEVDUJPO
!

)V-`XTIVI\QWVWN\PM1UIOM[C@QIVOWN\PM
[<PQVSQVO

8ZMNIKM
^QQ
%JTDFSOJOHUIF5IBUCZ8IJDI



<
BOH#JT0OUPMPHZ
ITSQVOIJW]\<PI\?PQKP1[,IZS


<PM.ZIUM_WZSWN)VITa[Q[



?
<PM4WOQKIT,ML]K\QWVWN\PM=VVIUMIJQTQ\aWN
[1VY]QZaQV\W\PM<PI\Ja?PQKP



?
<PI\Ja?PQKP\PM<
[)XXZWIKP
MV<PW][IVL3QVL[WN-V\Q\QM[)ZM


<PM*QVIZa;\Z]K\]ZIT7ZOIVQbI\QWVWN-V\Q\QM[



<PM7ZLMZWN\PM<
<PM,ML]K\QWVWN\PM8W[[QJQTQ\aWN4QUQ\MLJ]\



;]NãKQMV\Ta/ZW]VLML8ZWXW[Q\QWV[IJW]\<PI\Ja
+WV\MV\[
*QJTQWOZIXPa
<PM,IW


<PM,IZS





^Q
;IOMTa8WTQ\QK[I[8]JTQK8MZNWZUIVKM

IVO*Qs

8

BOH#JT1PMJUJDBM1IJMPTPQIZ


!!

?
<PM)K\]ITIVL8MZXM\]IT+ZQ[Q[WN0]UIV;WKQM\a
[8PQTW[WXPa")V1LMWTWOa'

6W\M[


<PM+I][M[WN\PM+ZQ[Q[


1VLM`


7XMZI\QVO\PM:M\]ZV"<PM;IOM
+WV\MV\[

QV
*Q
\PZW]OP
WV
_PQKP
VMML
WV
\PM
ZVITQ[\
QV
XI[[ML
1
NZWU
aMIZ[
QV
7VTa
WN
WV
\PQZL
1
0MQLMTJMZO
\PM
WV
I\
/MZUIV
8ZWNM[[WZ

>
IQXQVO
I
QV
LM^MTWXUMV\
QV
XZM[MV\
WN
ãZ[\
WN
PIL
*Q
WN

MUMZOML
Q\[
I\
I[
WN
+PQVM[M
I\
N\
1V
*MZSMTMa
PIJQTQ\I\QWV
IVL
\
Ua
[WKQI\QWV

I[
UILM
NMTTW_
IUW]V\
1V
M
\PM
_PQKP
JWWS
)
!
+PQVI
L]ZQVO
I
_MZM
_I[
?
QV
[MOU
ZM^Q^ML
+PQVM[M
UIVa
\PM
Q[
?
M`\ZIXWTI\Q^M
IK\Q^M
[KPWTIZ[P
JIKS
4IWbQ
\PM
KWZM
PIL
?
QV
JWWS
XIZ\

[KQMVKM
TI[\
KWV[]T\IV\
=VQ^MZ[Q\a
IVL
-VOTQ[P
N]TT
\W
\PQ[
S
_WZS
_Q\P
WN
V
ZM[MIZKP
NZWU
=VQ^MZ
\
!
JMOIV
\MIKPMZ
I\
WTNOIVO
)
IVL
BÜZKPMZ
XW[[QJTM
ZMNMZMM[
WN
0IZ^IZL
WTS[_IOMV_MZS
I
WN
[]J[MY]MV\
;\QN\]VO
N
[QbIJTM
Q\QM[
\P
aMIZ
ZMTQM^ML
QV
[\QXMVL
a
IVL
\PM
MNNWZ\
1V
\PM
\PM[M
UIRWZ
-VOTQ[P
UIQVTIVL
X]JTQ[PML
WN
[\]La
IZO]UMV\[
IVO
]ZOMV\
Ua
?
MV\[

[UITT
JWWS
ãK\QWV
WN
UWLMZV
JMMV
XWTQ\QK[
LZIN\[

1
JWWS[
IV
IVO
QX
ZMUIQVML
\ZIV[TI\QWV
J]\
\PM
\PM
\PM
J]ZVMZ
UMIV\QUM
)N\MZ

RWJ
[WTQL
*MZTQV
QV[\Q\]\M
Z]V
1V
KW]Z[M
IV
!
IVL
_WZSML
/MZUIVa
\QUM
\PQ[
I
QV
RW]
PIL
IVL
WN
WV
^MZ[QWV
IOZQK]T\]ZM
\PM
]OP
^WT]UM
ãZ[\
\MIKP
LZI
\PM
WN
aMIZ
\_W
Ua
QVO
*MZTQV

W_
+ITQNWZVQI
I
=VQ^MZ[Q\a
NIK\
TQVO]Q[\
OZIV\
I
_WZSQVO
[Q\a
\PM

_WZ
QV
:M[MIZ
_Q\P
0IZ^IZL
TI\M
1

PM
?
,./
*I]MZ
aMIZ
5]VQKP
XW[Q\QWV
-
MVW
[MMUML
\PI\
VM_
_ZQ\QVO
IVW\PMZ
8ZWNM[[WZ
I[
4MQLMV
I[[Q[\IV\
M`\MZVIT
XZWNM[[WZ
+WZVMTT
I\
=VQ^MZ[Q\a
\PM
I\
.ZMM
ZM[MIZKP
=VQ^MZ[Q\a
_I[
WN
aMIZ[
*MZTQV
\PM
JMOIV
QOQWV
I
ZMT
TWVO
<
LM\W]Z
QV

[IUM
5a

ML]KI\QWV
ZM[]T\ML
PIL
I
JMMV
WV
M`KT][Q^MT
\W
ãVQ[PML
8ZMNIKM
Q\[KZQ\QKITLQ[K][[QWVPI[IKK]U]TI\ML <PMKWZMQLMI[_MZMLM ^MTWXMLQV
WZ \PM 0]UIV _I[ OMVMZW][ MVW]OP \W QV^Q\M UM I[ I NMTTW_ QV\W Q\[ ;WKQM\a
[Q[ IVL Q\ _I[ JWWS 1V ! 1 []JUQ\\ML Q\ QV /MZUIV I[ I PIJQTQ\I\QWV \PM
_WZS WV UWLMZV +PQVI ?PQTM OIQVQVO [WUM M`XMZ\Q[M QV \PQ[ VM_ ãMTL Ua
V 1V[\Q\]\M _I[ ãMTL WN KTI[[QKIT +PQVM[M [\]LQM[ _PQTM \PM NWK][ WN \PM *MZTQ
)[ KP
_I[ JMO]V \PMV IVL KWV\QV]ML QV \PM NWTTW_QVO +WUUMV\IZa \PM IVO *Q
.MTTW_ <PM ! QV *MZSMTMa _PMZM 1 [XMV\ I _WVLMZN]T aMIZ I[ I 0IZSVM[[
PQ[ JWWS IVL \PZMM 5a OZI\Q\]LM NWZ \PM [XQZQ\]IT IVL UI\MZQIT []XXWZ\ WN
UMTa \_MV\a \PQ[ JWWS \WWS I[ UIVa aMIZ[ I[ IVO *Q Q\[ []JRMK\ TQ^ML VI
P \PQ[ _WZS WN \ISMV UIVa aMIZ[ IVL [M^MZIT W\PMZ JWWS[ \W ãVQ[ 1\ PI[ VW_
Ja

WZ\
ãVQ[P
=VQ^MZ[Q\a

JM\_MMV
W^MZ
WN
UW\PMZ
\PI\
JZWILUQVLMLVM[[
[XQZQ\]IT
\PM
QUXW[M[
_QTTQVO
M^MV
1
LIa
+WUUMV\I\WZ"
VM^MZ


[
\PM
\PIVS[


ZM_WZSQVO

_Q\P
Ja
LMLQKI\M
\PQ[
WZS
\QWV[
J]Z[\[
QV
I\QWV[
\PI\

]VJM
+ZIN\
\PQ[
W\PM
_Q\P
IVKM
IN\MZ

ãVQ[PML
"
<
\PIVSML
UIVa
4IWbQ
_WZS
\PM
<
IVL
\ZIV[UQ[[QWV
+I\PMZQVM
WN
\PM


TWVO\MZU

WN

;
I]\PWZ
IVITa[Q[
WV
6M_
WN
1V
L
PI[
WTLMZ
\W
_I[
[]XXWZ\
?PMV
NM^MZQ[P
\WTL
+PQVM[M
UIV][KZQX\
[MK\QWV[
[PM
QVKT]LM
;QVKM
[\ZM\KPM[
_I[
I
PIL
M^MV\]IT
P
MP
M\MZVIT
MY]ITTa
XZWUQ[M
+PQVM[M
TI[\
IVO
_W]TL
,IWLM
\PIVS
\PQ[
[Q[\MZ
IVO
IVL
\PM

WV
WN
XWZ\
WN
?
UM
bM
M`\

PMZ
\PM
;\I\M
=VQ^MZ[Q\a
0MQLMTJMZO6W^MUJMZ
O
JMKI][M

_PQTM
a
\PM
UIV][KZQX\
\PM
I[[Q[\IV\[
IVL
,Z
ITT
IL^QKM#
^QM_
IVL
\PQ[^WT]UM\WPMZ
OI^M
_PQKP


\PM
\I\M
J]\
VM_
\PW[M
WN
_PWU
ZM[\
SQVL
A
_WZS

XIQVN]T
8ZM[[
>
[PWZ\
5a
JMMV
LI]OP\MZ
WN
5IZ\PI
\W
JWZV
WN
!
X]JTQK
1
_Q[P
\]ITTa
QV
PMZ
_WZS
\PM
XPQTW[WXPa
_I[
1
KWUXTM\ML
<PM[M
[MMUML
TWVO
^QQQ
<PM
\PM
KWUXTM\QWV
[PM
WN
JWZV
WN
UIV][KZQX\
+PQVM[M
P]VO
?