Greek Rhetoric Before Aristotle

Richard Leo Enos

Description

Recent archaeological discoveries, coupled with long-lost but now available epigraphical evidence, and a more expansive view of literary sources, provide new and dramatic evidence of the emergence of rhetoric in ancient Greece. Many of these artifacts, gathered through onsite fieldwork in Greece, are analyzed in this revised and expanded edition of Greek Rhetoric Before Aristotle. This new evidence, along with recent developments in research methods and analysis, reveal clearly that long before Aristotle’s Rhetoric, long before rhetoric was even stabilized into formal systems of study in Classical Athens, nascent, pre-disciplinary “rhetorics” were emerging throughout Greece.

Informations

• Publié par: Parlor Press, LLC
• Date de parution: 29 novembre 2011
• Nombre de lectures: 0
• EAN13: 9781602352148
• Langue: English
• Poids de l'ouvrage: 3 Mo

Extrait

enos Greek Rhetoric Before ARistotle Greek Rhetoric

R

Revised and Expanded Edition

Richard Leo Enos

Greek Rhetoric Before Aristotle

Lauer SerIes In RHetorIc and ComposItIon Séîéŝ Eîôŝ: Càéîé ôbbŝ, Pàîçîà Sûîvà, Tôàŝ Rîçké, à Jéîé Bày

Té Làûé Séîéŝ î Réôîç à Côôŝîîô ôôŝ é çôîbûîôŝ Jàîçé Làûé àŝ àé ô é éégéçé ô Réôîç à Côôŝîîô àŝ à îŝçîîày ŝûy. ï ûbîŝéŝ ŝçôàŝî à çàîéŝ ô Pôéŝŝô Làûé’ŝ vàîé wôk î é îŝôy ô wîé éôîç, îŝçîîàîy î çôôŝîîô ŝûîéŝ, çôéôày éàgôgîçà éôy, à wîé îéàçy éôy à éŝéàç.

OtHer Books in tHe Series

Retorîc’s Eartly Realm: Heîdegger, Sopîstry, and te Gorgîan Kaîrosby Béà Aà Mîé (2011) Téçé, from Neoclassîcîsm to Postmodernîsm: Understandîng Wrîtîng as a Useful, Teacable Artby Kéy Péé (2011) Walkîng and Talkîng Femînîst Retorîcs: Landmark Essays and Controversîes, é- îé by Lîà Bûçàà à Kàéé J. Ryà (2010) Transformîng Englîs Studîes: New Voîces în an Emergîng Genre, éîé by Lôî Oŝégàà, Jé Lûwîg, à Jî Nûgé (2009) Ancîent Non-Greek Retorîcs, éîé by Càô S. Lîŝô à Rôbéà A. Bîkéy (2009) Roman Retorîc: Revolutîon and te Greek Influence, Révîŝé à Exàé Eîîô, by Rîçà Léô Eôŝ (2008) Storîes of Mentorîng: Teory and Praxîs, éîé by Mîçéé F. Ebé à LyÉé Léwîŝ Gàîé (2008) Wrîters Wîtout Borders: Wrîtîng and Teacîng în Troubled Tîmes by Ly Z. Bôô (2008) 1977: A Cultural Moment în Composîtîon, by Bé ézé, Jàçk Sézé, à Wéy Sàé (2008) Te Promîse and Perîls of Wrîtîng Program Admînîstratîon,éîé by Tééŝà Eôŝ à Sàé Bôôwà (2008) Untenured Faculty as Wrîtîng Program Admînîstrators: Instîtutîonal Practîces and Polîtîcs, éîé by Débà Fàk Déw à Aîçé ôîg (2007) Networked Process: Dîssolvîng Boundarîes of Process and Post-Processéé by Fôŝé (2007) Composîng a Communîty: A Hîstory of Wrîtîng Across te Currîculum, éîé by Sûŝà . MçLéô à Màgô ïîŝ Sôvé (2006) Hîstorîcal Studîes of Wrîtîng Program Admînîstratîon: Indîvîduals, Communîtîes, and te Formatîon of a Dîscîplîne, éîé by Bàbàà L’Eàéîé à Lîŝà Màŝàgéô (2004). Wîé ô é WPA Béŝ Bôôk Awà ô 2004–2005. Retorîcs, Poetîcs, and Cultures: Reigurîng College Englîs Studîes(Exàé Eîîô) by Jàéŝ A. Béî (2003)

GREEK RHETORIC BEFORE ARISTOTLE

Revîsed and Expanded Edîtîon

Rîçà Léô Eôŝ

Pàô Péŝŝ Anderson, Sout Carolîna www.àôéŝŝ.çô

Pàô Péŝŝ LLC, Aéŝô, Sôû Càôîà, USA

© 2012 by Pàô Péŝŝ A îgŝ éŝévé. Pîé î é Uîé Sàéŝ ô Aéîçà

S A N: 2 5 4 - 8 8 7 9

Lîbày ô Côgéŝŝ Cààôgîg-î-Pûbîçàîô Dàà

Eôŝ, Rîçà Léô. Géék éôîç béôé Aîŝôé / Rîçà Léô Eôŝ. -- Rév. à éxàé é.  . ç. -- (Làûé ŝéîéŝ î éôîç à çôôŝîîô) ïçûéŝ bîbîôgàîçà éééçéŝ à îéx.  ïSBN 978-1-60235-212-4 (bk. : àk. àé) -- ïSBN 978-1-60235-213-1 (àçôvé : àk. àé) -- ïSBN 978-1-60235-214-8 (àôbé ébôôk) -- ïSBN 978-1-60235-215-5 (éûb)  1. Géék îéàûé--îŝôy à çîîçîŝ--Téôy, éç. 2. Réôîç, Açîé. ï. Tîé. PA401.E55 2011 880.9’001--ç22  2011010796

Côvé éŝîg by Dàvî Bàkéŝéy. Côvé îàgé: "A Réàîg ô ôé" by Làwéçé Aà-Tàéà. 1885. Oî ô çàvàŝ. Côûéŝy ô Té Pîàéîà Mûŝéû ô A / A Réŝôûçé, Néw Yôk. Uŝé by éîŝŝîô. Pîé ô àçî-éé àé.

Pàô Péŝŝ, LLC îŝ à îééé ûbîŝé ô ŝçôày à àé îéŝ î î à ûîéîà ôàŝ. Tîŝ bôôk îŝ àvàîàbé î àé, çô à Aôbé éBôôk ôàŝ ô Pàô Péŝŝ ô é Wô Wîé Wéb à :// www.àôéŝŝ.çô ô ôûg ôîé à bîçk-à-ôà bôôkŝôéŝ. Fô ŝûbîŝŝîô îôàîô ô ô î ôû àbôû Pàô Péŝŝ ûbîçàîôŝ, wîé ô Pàô Péŝŝ, 3015 Bàçkébéy Dîvé, Aéŝô, Sôû Càôîà, 29621, ô éàî éîô@àôéŝŝ.çô.

To Natan, Alex, Sus, and Quîncy . . .

v

Foreword to te Revîsed and Expanded Edîtîon

Sîgîîçà àvàçéŝ î é îé ô çàŝŝîçà éôîç àvé béé àé ŝîçé é 1993 ûbîçàîô ôGreek Retorîc Before Arîstotle.Téŝé àvàçéŝ—ŝôé ô wîç àé éîôé àé î îŝ éàçé—àvé çôîbûé ô ôy ô ŝévéà éw çàéŝ bû àŝô ô éw éôéî- çà, éôôôgîçà, à çîîçà éŝéçîvéŝ. Fô éxàé, éŝéàç ôé ô é îvéŝé àîéŝàîôŝ ô wôé’ŝ éôîçŝ àŝ ô ôy éxàé é îŝôy ô éôîç bû àŝô é îgî ààééŝ ô wà wé àvé çôŝîéé “éôîç” ô bé ô wôé à ôé évîôûŝy éxçûé ô àgîàîzé gôûŝ. Sîîày, ôŝôé éôîçà éôy àŝ évéàé é bééîŝ ô éçôgîzîg ôîîçà, ŝôçîà, à ŝyçôôgîçà àçôŝ à îûéçé ô ôy éôîçà ŝîûàîôŝ bû àŝô é véy éàîîéŝ îvôvé î é çôgîîô à éxéŝŝîô ô éôîçà îŝçôûŝé. Néw îày àéîà ô éôîç î é àçîé wô îŝ béçôîg àvàîàbé àûày, à àvàçéŝ î éçôôgy î é àŝ éw éçàéŝ àvé àé é îŝîbûîô ô ŝûç àéîà àvàî- àbé î à béà à wî à éàŝé à éàîé îŝôîàŝ ô éôîç évé çôû àvé îàgîé ôŝŝîbé. A éŝéçîày gôô îûŝàîô ô ŝûç îôvàîvé wôk à bô ŝyéŝîzéŝ à ààyzéŝ é ôŝ çûé éŝéàç î éôîç îŝTe Sage Handbook of Retorîcal Studîes (2009). Gîvé ŝûç àvàçéŝ î é îé ô éôîç, wé wôû ô wé ô àûŝé à ééç ô ôû ŝàîg ôîŝ. Oé ô é îày ôîŝ ô ééçîô ŝôû bé ôû éééçé ô éŝéàç éôŝ à ôû ŝôûçéŝ ô îqûîy. ï ày wàyŝ, é ŝôûçéŝ à wé ŝééç ô ûŝé ô ôû îŝôy àé îé ô é ŝééçîô ô ôû éŝéàç éôŝ. Oû à- îîôà àvéûé ô kôwégé ô çàŝŝîçà éôîç àŝ béé é éŝçé ô àûŝçîŝ àŝŝé àôg ôûg Aîqûîy, é Mîé Agéŝ, é Réàîŝŝàçé, à Môé éîôŝ ô é bôôk àîîô. Té ŝééçîô ô éŝé ŝôûçéŝ àŝ îûéçé ôû éôŝ ô éŝéàç, à î îŝ îŝ çôîîô à é éàçé àéŝŝéŝ.

vîî

vîîî

Foreword to te Revîsed and Expanded Edîtîon

Càŝŝîçà éôîç îŝ éîçé àûày by éw îôàîô à îŝ ô ô é “bôôk” àîîô—àîçûày ô é àéàŝ ô à- çàéôôgy, éîgày, îé àŝ, à éw éîà éîééŝ î àçîvà ŝûîéŝ. Wî à ô îŝ àbûàçé ô ôéîà îôàîô, ôwévé, wé çôîûé ô éŝéàç çàŝŝîçà éôîç by àîîôà àôàçéŝ. Tà îŝ, ày ŝçôàŝ béîévé à çàŝŝîçà éôîç ŝôû bé ŝû- îé by çàŝŝîçà àôàçéŝ. Uôûàéy, “çàŝŝîçà àôàçéŝ” àé ô éày “çàŝŝîçà” à à bû àé Vîçôîà; à îŝ, é éôŝ ô ŝûyîg çàŝŝîçà éôîç àvé béé bàŝé ô é éôŝ ûŝé î çàŝŝîçà ŝûîéŝ ô é àŝ wô çéûîéŝ. Wé àvé, ôvé ôŝé wô çéûîéŝ, ŝô ŝôgy çô-éxîŝé Vîçôîà éôŝ wî é ŝûy ô çàŝŝîçà éôîç à ôŝé Vîçôîà éôŝ àvé béé îéxîçàby wéé ô (à çôûŝé àŝ béîg) ŝôéîg à géw ôû ô A- îqûîy. Aŝ à éŝû ô îŝ çôûŝîô, é éwéŝ, à ôé é ôŝ ŝéŝîîvé à îŝîgû, éôéîçà éŝéçîvéŝ à îôvàîvé îŝ- ôîôgàîçà éôŝ àé îŝîŝŝé ô ô ôé éàŝô à à éy àçk é (Vîçôîà) àîîô. Sçôàŝ àvé ŝô çôŝéy çô-éxîŝé çàŝŝîçà éôîç wî ôg ôûàé Vîçôîà éŝéàç àçîçéŝ à éy àé ûwîîg ô îŝk béîg “ûàîû” by éàîg ô ôg- éŝàbîŝé éôŝ (Eôŝ, “Càŝŝîçà” 285et passîm). Wîé éé îŝ ô ôûb à wé éŝàbîŝé éŝéàç àôàçéŝ àvé ûç ô ôé, îŝ évîŝé à éxàé éîîô éxàîéŝ à àŝŝéŝŝéŝ îôvàîvé éôéîçà gàîŝ à àéà éŝéàç éûîŝîçŝ à ôé ûîû éw àôàçéŝ î é îŝôîôgày ô çàŝŝîçà éôîç à çôé- é ôg-éŝàbîŝé éŝéàç àçîçéŝ.One of te prîmary new ap- proaces groundîng tîs volume îs arcaeologîcal retorîc, a metod and a mentalîty tat seeks to excavate and reconstruct any and all artîfacts îndîgenous to te contextual envîronment tat elp to provîde a sensîtîve explanatîon of te relatîonsîp between tougt and expressîon. Gîvé é vôûé’ŝ ôîéàîô ôwà àçàéôôgîçà éôîç, wé wôû ô wé ô évîéw é ŝàîg ôîŝ ô îŝ àôàç by îŝçûŝŝ- îg é îéé îîàîôŝ ô àîîôà éŝéàç éôŝ î çàŝŝîçà éôîç. Nô àgûéŝ éé ô bé àvàçé (àgàî) à wàà é bééîŝ ô îŝôîçà éŝéàç î éôîç. Réôîç àŝ àéày béé çéày éŝàbîŝé àŝ à ŝôçîà, ôîîçà à éûçàîôà ôçé î A- îqûîy. Wà ôéŝ éé ô bé àgûé àé é wàyŝ à wé y ô à- vàçé ŝéŝîîvé ûéŝàîgŝ ô é àûé à îàç ô éôîç. Cûé îŝîgŝ ô wôk î ôŝôé à çîîçà éôy àvé çàé ô qûéŝîô é éŝûîôŝ à îvé çôvéîôà éŝéàç

Foreword to te Revîsed and Expanded Edîtîon

îx

éôŝ à évé wà îŝ çôŝîéé “éôîç.” ï, àŝ éîôé î é éàîé éxàé, wé çôŝîé éôîç ô bé ôy ôvéy àgôîŝîç àçŝ ô éŝûàŝîô à ôççû î çîvîç çééŝ, é wé çôŝàî ôû vîéw ô ôy ôé (éôîày àé) îéŝîô ô éôîç î ŝôçîà îéàçîô à, by éàû, éxçûé ôéŝ, ŝûç àŝ wôé (ŝéé, é.g., Bîzzé àŝŝî). ôwévé, béçàûŝé wôé wéé ôày ô gîvé éqûà àççéŝŝ ô çîvîç ûçîôŝ, ŝôû wé éŝûé à éy à ô “éôîç” ô éî ôw, ô à éy évé ûŝé éî éôîç ô ŝôçîà éŝ? Pôŝôé wôk àŝ çàûŝé ûŝ ô ééç ô ôû ôw ŝàîg ôîŝ à, î îŝ îŝàçé, çàûîôŝ ô ô éxçûé “éôîçŝ” à ô ô çôô ô é égéôîç éôîç ô é éîô à wîî é çûûé béîg éxàîé. ï wé àé ô çôŝîé àçàéôôgîçà éôîç àŝ îôà ô é éŝéàç éôŝ ô îŝôîçà éôîç, à à é vàîîy ô ôû éôŝ (àŝ wé àŝ é éôy îvîg ôŝé éôŝ) îŝ àjûîçàé by ôû àçàéîç çôûîy, é é évîéçé à wé ûŝé ô àŝà ôû “àgûé” îŝ ô ààôû îôàçé. Réŝéàç î îŝôîçà éôîç îvôvéŝ ôé à wà îŝ îé ô à àgé. Réôîç, ô bé ŝûé, ày àvé béé éçôé ô à àgé, bû é éôîç îŝé çàé ô îé î à éà, yàîç ŝîûàîô ôççûîg à à ôé î îé. Ué- ŝàîg é çôéx à îîîày ôé é éôîç îŝ çîîçà î wé àé ô àvàçé éàîg béyô wà àéàŝ ô à àgé. Tô ààî kôwégé ô à çôéx, wé ûŝ y ô éôûçé é évîôé wîî wîç à îéçé ô îŝçôûŝé wàŝ çéàé. Tô é-çéàé à ŝçéé wé ûŝ ôôk ô ày à à àîàçŝ à ôé îŝîg ô é çûûà çôéx ô é éôîç ûé éxàîàîô. Té ŝàé yôîç çôŝàîŝ à àvé àîîôày îîé ôû éŝéàç éôŝ î çàŝŝîçà éôîç çôû àŝô bé àîé ô ŝé- îôŝé çûûà çôŝàîŝ. Aéŝ wàŝ à ôîà ŝîé ô éôîç. Sô ôîà, î àç, à wé bô é ô gééàîzé Aéîà éô- îç àŝ (Pà-)ééîç à ô ûŝé Aéîà éôîç àŝ à ŝàà ô jûgé ô ôé çôéôày éôîç(ŝ) ô é ééîç wô. Yé, ôŝôé wôk àŝ ŝôw à évéy ŝôçîéy àŝ à éôîç, bû ô à ô éŝé éôîçŝ àé àîéŝé î à ŝîîà àŝîô, àŝ îŝ çôvîç- îgy évéàé î é éîé vôûé ô Càô S. Lîŝô à Rôbéà A. Bîkéy,RetorîcBefore and Beyond te Greeks(2004). Fô éxàé, béçàûŝé Aéîà à Sàà ŝôçîéîéŝ àé ŝô ààîçày îéé, à Sàà éôîç wôû ûéŝààby àéà ô bé à îéé à à Aéîà éôîç béçàûŝé éî éŝéçîvé éôîçŝ wôû bé