Reason, Normativity and Law

A. Pinheiro Walla and M. RuhiDemiray

Description

2019

Pinheiro Walla, Alice. "Kant and Climate Change." Forthcoming in Ben Eggleston and Dale E. Miller (eds.) Moral Theory and Climate Change: Ethical Perspectives on a Warming Planet, Routledge.

　

Pinheiro Walla, Alice. "Kant and the Wisdom of Oedipus." Forthcoming in Jahrbuch Praktische Philosophie in globaler Perspektive / Yearbook Practical Philosophy in a Global Perspective, 2019.

　

2018

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Posesión común de la tierra y derecho cosmopolita" (transl. of "Common Possession of the Earth and Cosmopolitan Right"). Las Torres de Lucca, 13, número especial "Kant y la filosofía política: pueblos soberanos sobre una misma tierra", Macarena Marey (ed.), december 2018.

　

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Private Property and the Possibility of Consent: Immanuel Kant and Social Contract Theory." In: Krasnoff, Larry; Sanchez Madrid, Nuria; Satne, Paula (eds.): Kant's Doctrine of Right in the Twenty-first Century. Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 2018.

　

Pinheiro Walla, Alice "Global government or global governance? Realism and idealism in Kant's legal theory." Journal of Global Ethics vol. 13 (2018) issue 3, pp. 312-325.

　

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Kant on Cosmopolitan Education for Peace". Con-textos Kantianos, Vol. 7, June 2018, pp. 332-347.

　

2017

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Kant’s Politics in Context. By Reidar Maliks." The Philosophical Quarterly, Volume 67, Issue 266, 1 January 2017, pp. 207–209.

　

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Kant on Freedom of Thought." In: Tomaszewska, Anna; Hämäläinen, Hasse (eds.): The Sources of Secularism : Enlightenment and Beyond. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2017, pp. 189-206.

　

2016

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, Review of Lara Denis and Oliver Sensen (eds.): Kant's Lectures on Ethics: A Critical Guide. Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, 2016.

　

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Common Possession of the Earth and Cosmopolitan Right", Kant-Studien vol. 107 (2016) issue 1, pp. 160-178.

　

2015

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Kant’s Moral Theory and Demandingness". Ethical Theory and Moral Practice vol. 18 (2015) issue 4, pp. 731-743.

　

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Local Desire Satisfaction and Long Term Wellbeing : revisiting the Gout Sufferer of Kant’s Groundwork". Belgrade Philosophical Annual (2015) issue 28, pp. 31-44.

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "When the strictest right is the greatest wrong: Kant on Fairness," Estudos Kantianos vol. 3, n. 01 (2015).

　

2014

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Human Nature and the Right to Coerce in Kant's Doctrine of Right", Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie vol. 96 (2014) issue 1. pp. 126-139.

　

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, ‘A Commentary on Anna Stilz, "Nations, States, and Territory" and Lea Ypi, "A Permissive Theory of Territorial Rights."’ Territory and Justice Symposia 3 : Kantian Theories of Territorial Rights, 2014 edition.

　

2013

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Book review : Kant and Cosmopolitanism: The Philosophical Ideal of World Citzenship. By Pauline Kleingeld." Journal for Eighteenth-Century Studies, 2013

　

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Elisabeth Ellis: Kant's Political Theory: Interpretations and Applications." ID: International Dialogue : a Multidisciplinary Journal of World Affairs, 2013.

　

Pinheiro Walla, Alice, "Virtue and Prudence in a Footnote of the Metaphysics of Morals (MS VI: 433n)." Jahrbuch für Recht und Ethik / Annual review of law and ethics vol. 21 (2013) . pp. 307-323.

· “Politik Sorunun Normatif Çözümü Olarak Adalet Fikri” [“The Idea of Justice as the Normative Solution to the Political Problem”], Felsefe Tartışmaları 55, December 2018.

· "Public Religion and Secular State: A Kantian Approach", Diametros 54, December 2017, pp. 30-55.

· "The Intrinsic Normativity of Law in Light of Kant`s Doctrine of Right", Con-Textos Kantianos 3, June 2016, pp.161-187.

· "The Dichotomy between Piety and Zealotry: Reflections on the Relation between Religiosity and Democratic Secularism", METU Studies in Development 42 (3), 2015, pp.339-354.

· "Natural Law Theory, Legal Positivism, and the Normativity of Law", European Legacy: Toward New Paradigms 20 (8), 2015, pp.1-20.

How should we act? How should the world be organised? This new anthology on Kant’s practical philosophy guides the reader from the general question of the nature of reasons and rationality in Kant’s philosophical system to the Kantian task of promoting justice and peace at the global level. Contributions to this volume show how the Kantian idea of reason as a source of normativity is grounded, and which implications and applications the Kantian approach might bring about. The volume covers three areas – meta-ethics, political thought and theory, and applied politics – and although these are different spheres of thought, they are interconnected in a fundamental way through Kant’s account of normativity as derived from reason. The volume provides an overview of recent debates in Kant scholarship and groundbreaking new applications of Kant’s theory to current affairs.

List of Illustrations
Contributors
Introduction Alice Pinheiro Walla and Ruhi Demiray
Part I: Reason and Normativity
1. Can Kantian Constructivism Avoid Realist Commitments? Michael Lyons
2. Staying Philosophically on the Surface: Constitutivist and Naturalist Quests for Normativity Sorin Baiasu
3. The Politics of Reason Sofie Christine Møller
Part II: Reason and Legal Order
4. Justice, Citizenship and the Kingdom of Ends Sarah Holtman
5. Juridical Law as a Categorical Imperative Marie Newhouse
6. Provisional and Private Legality in Kant Christoph Hanish
7. Why Human Dignity Cannot Be the Basis of Human Rights, At Least on Kantian Grounds Matthé Scholten
8. Kant’s Idea of Law and Human Rights Ruhi Demiray
Part III: Kant and Contemporary Political Issues
9. Forcible Dispossession of Territory and State Legitimacy: A Kantian Account Sylvie Loriaux
10. Private Property and Territorial Rights: A Kantian Alternative to Contemporary Debates Alice Pinheiro Walla
11. Kant's Cosmopolitan Right and Human Dignity in European Asylum Law Domenica Dreyer-Plum
Index

Sujets

• Philosophie
• Philosophie politique
• Éthique et morale
• Moral Philosophy
• Philosophie et théologie
• Philosophy
• Ethics

Informations

• Publié par: University of Wales Press
• Date de parution: 01 février 2020
• Nombre de lectures: 0
• EAN13: 9781786835130
• Langue: English
• Poids de l'ouvrage: 16 Mo

Extrait

p o l i t i c a l p h i l o s o p h y n o w

Chief Editor of the Series: Hôwà Wîîàms, Abéyswyh Unîvésîy, Wàés

Associate Editors: Wôfgàng Késîng, Unîvésîy ôf Kîé, Gémàny Rénàô Cîsî, Wîfî Làuîé Unîvésîy, Wàéôô, Cànàà Susàn Mé Shé, Bôsôn Côégé, Màssàchusés, USA Dàvî Bôuché, Càîff Unîvésîy, Wàés

Affiliate Editors: Sévén B. Smîh, Yàé Unîvésîy, USA Péé Nîchôsôn, Unîvésîy ôf Yôk, Engàn

Political Philosophy Nowà séîés whîch éàs wîh àuhôs, îs ôpîcs àn péîôs în pôîîcà phîôsôphy fôm hé péspécîvé ôf héî éévàncé ô cuén ébàés. Thé séîés péséns à spéà ôf subjécs àn pôîns ôf vîéw fôm vàîôus àîîôns whîch încué Euôpéàn àn Néw Wô ébàés în pôîîcà phîôsôphy.

Also in series Kant’sDôcîné ôf Rîghin the Twenty-first Century Lày Kàsnôff, Nuîà Sánchéz Màî àn Pàuà Sàné

Hegel and Marx: After the Fall of Communism Dàvî MàcGégô

Politics and Teleology in Kant Eîé by Pàu Fômôsà, Avéy Gômàn àn Tàîànà Pàôné

Identity, Politics and the Novel: The Aesthetic Moment Iàn Fàsé

Kant on Sublimity and Morality Jôshuà Ràymàn

Politics and Metaphysics in Kant Eîé by Sôîn Bàîàsu, Sàmî Pîhsôm àn Hôwà Wîîàms

Nietzsche and Napoleon: The Dionysian Conspiracy Dôn Dômbôwsky

Nietzsche On Theognis of Megara Rénàô Cîsî àn Oscà Véásquéz

Francis Fukuyama and the end of history Hôwà Wîîàms, Dàvî Suîvàn àn E. Gwynn Màhéws

Kant’s Political Legacy: Human Rights, Peace, Progress Luîgî Càànî

p o l i t i c a l p h i l o s o p h y n o w

Reason, Normativity and Law neW ESSàYS IN KàNTIàN pHILOSOPHY

EdITed BY aLICe pINHeIrO wàLLà àNd MeHmeT RuHI DemIràY

UniVERsity oF walEs pREss • 2020

© Thé Cônîbuôs, 2020

A îghs ésévé. Nô pà ôf hîs bôôk mày bé épôucé în àny màéîà fôm (încuîng phôôcôpyîng ô sôîng î în àny méîum by éécônîc méàns àn whéhé ô nô ànsîény ô încîén- ày ô sômé ôhé usé ôf hîs pubîcàîôn) wîhôu hé wîén pémîssîôn ôf hé côpyîgh ôwné éxcép în àccôàncé wîh hé pôvîsîôns ôf hé Côpyîgh, Désîgns àn Pàéns Ac 1988. Appî- càîôns fô hé côpyîgh ôwné’s wîén pémîssîôn ô épôucé àny pà ôf hîs pubîcàîôn shôu bé àéssé ô hé Unîvé- sîy ôf Wàés Péss, Unîvésîy Régîsy, Kîng Ewà VII Avénué, CàîffCF103NS.

www.uwp.co.uk

British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A cààôgué écô fô hîs bôôk îs àvàîàbé fôm hé Bîîsh Lîbày.

ISBN 978-1-78683-512-3 é-ISBN 978-1-78683-513-0

Thé îghs ôf hé cônîbuôs ô bé îénîfîé às àuhôs ôf hîs wôk hàvé béén àsséé în àccôàncé wîh sécîôns 77, 78 àn 79 ôf hé Côpyîgh, Désîgns àn Pàéns Ac 1988.

Typésé by Màîé Dôhéy Pîné by CPI Anôny Rôwé, Mékshàm

Contents

Lîs ôf Fîgués Lîs ôf Cônîbuôs

Inôucîôn Alice Pinheiro Walla and Ruhi Demiray

Part I: Reason and Normativity 1 Càn Kànîàn Cônsucîvîsm Avôî Réàîs Cômmîméns? Michael Lyons

2

3

SàyîngPhîôsôphîcàyônhéSufàcé: Cônsîuîvîs àn Nàuàîs Quéss fô Nômàîvîy Sorin Baiasu

Thé Pôîîcs ôf Réàsôn Sofie Møller

Part II: Reason and Legal Order 4 Jusîcé, Cîîzénshîp àn hé Kîngôm ôf Ens Sarah Holtman

5

6

Juîîcà Làw às à Càégôîcà Impéàîvé M. E. Newhouse

Pôvîsîônà àn Pîvàé Légàîy în Kàn Christoph Hanisch

vîî îx

1

17

38

6

8

1

5

105

126

7

8

WhyHumànDîgnîyCànnôBéhéBàsîsôf Humàn Rîghs, à Léàs Nô ôn Kànîàn Gôuns Matthé Scholten

Kàn’s Iéà ôf Làw àn Humàn Rîghs Ruhi Demiray

Part III: Kant and Contemporary Political Issues 9 Fôcîbé Dîspôsséssîôn ôf Téîôy àn Sàé Légîîmàcy: A Kànîàn Accôun Sylvie Loriaux

10

11

PîvàéPôpéyànTéîôîàRîghs:AKànîàn Aénàîvé ô Cônémpôày Débàés Alice Pinheiro Walla

Kàn’sCôsmôpôîànRîghànHumànDîgnîy în Euôpéàn Asyum Làw Domenica Dreyer-Plum

Bîbîôgàphy Inéx

147

170

193

213

233

255 269

List of Figures

Fîgué 1

Fîgué 2

Fîgué 3

M. E. Néwhôusé, ‘Twô Typés ôf Môà Làw’, 108 p. 130. M. E. Néwhôusé, ‘Juîîcà Làwgîvîngs 115 Càn bé Répéséné în Twô Wàys’, p. 139. M. E. Néwhôusé, ‘Kàn’s Récusîvé Ehîcà 117 Pîncîpé’, p. 141.

List of Contributors

Sorin BaiasuPôféssô ôf Phîôsôphy à Kééé Unîvésîy (UK). îs Hé îs hé àuhô ôfKant and Sartre: Re-discovering Critical Ethics, àn éîô ô cô-éîô ôfPolitics and Metaphysics in Kant,Kant on Practical Justification: Interpretive Essays,Comparing Kant and Sartre ànSincerity in Politics and International Relations. Hé hàs pubîshé pàpés în, àmông ôhés,Kant-Studien,Kantian Review,Studi KantianiànSartre Studies International. Hé îs hé îécô ôf hé Kééé-Oxfô-S Anéws Kànîàn Réséàch Céné (KOSAK) àn cô-cônvénô ôf hé Kànîàn Sànîng Gôup ôf hé Euôpéàn Cônsôîum fô Pôîîcà Réséàch.

Ruhi Demirayîs àn Eînséîn Junîô Schôà bàsé à hé Féîé Unî- vésîy în Béîn sîncé Jànuày 2019. Pévîôusy, hé wàs Phîîpp Schwàz féôw ôf hé Aéxàné vôn Humbô Fôunàîôn à hé Unîvésîy ôf Sîégén, à Màîé Cuîé féôw à Kééé Unîvésîy, àn Fubîgh ôcôà éséàch féôw à hé Unîvésîy ôf Wîscôn- sîn-Mîwàukéé. Hé hôs à PhD în pôîîcà scîéncé fôm Mîé Eàs Téchnîcà Unîvésîy àn wôks ôn pôîîcà àn égà phîôsô- phy. Hé îs pàîcuày înéésé în humàn îghs héôîés, hé ué ôf àw àn hé sàé, àn Kàn’s pôîîcà-égà phîôsôphy.

Domenica Dreyer-Plumîs à pôsôcôà éséàché în Pôîîcà Scî- éncé à hé Unîvésîy ôf Bônn, Gémàny. Hé éséàch înééss àé côsmôpôîànîsm, égà héôy àn hé phîôsôphy ôf Euôpéàn Unîôn àw. Shé écéîvé à Bàchéô égéé (BA) fôm hé Unîvésîy ôf Bônn, à Màsé ôf Phîôsôphy (MPhî) fôm hé Unîvésîy ôf Càmbîgé àn à PhD în Pôîîcà Scîéncé fôm hé Unîvésîy ôf Bônn.

Christoph Hanisch îs àn Assîsàn Pôféssô à Ohîô Unîvésîy. Béfôé jôînîng OU’s phîôsôphy épàmén în 2016, hé wàs à pôsôcôà féôw à hé Unîvésîy ôf Vîénnà àn à mémbé ôf hé Euôpéàn Réséàch Côuncî éséàch pôjéc ‘Dîsôîôns ôf